Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or any of the makers named here.
When you shop for non toxic pans, the useful question is what actually touches your food. Four pan materials give a clear answer, and each maker below names the material of its cooking surface: seasoned cast iron, stainless steel, seasoned carbon steel and ceramic-coated aluminum.
For most kitchens, buy the Lodge 12 inch cast iron skillet first: iron with baked-on oil, made in the USA, and Lodge says it is made without PFAS. The box below gives the pick for each other material.
What Touches Your Food in Each Pan?
| Lodge cast iron | All-Clad D3 stainless | Made In carbon steel | GreenPan Valencia Pro ceramic | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cooking surface | Cast iron seasoned with “100% natural vegetable oil” | Stainless steel over an aluminum core | Carbon steel “pre-seasoned with a mixture of shea nut oil and coconut oil” | “Diamond-infused ceramic nonstick coating” on hard anodized aluminum |
| PFAS statement | Made without PFAS | None on the product page | Made without PFAS, PFOA and PTFE | Nonstick made without intentionally added PFAS |
| Heat | Any stovetop including induction, oven, grill, campfire | Induction, oven and broiler to 600°F | Induction, oven, grill; “Safe up to 1200F” | Induction, oven to 600°F |
| Washing | Hand wash, dry, oil | Hand wash with soap and sponge, dry at once | Hand wash; no dish soap, no dishwasher | Soft sponge and warm soapy water; hand washing recommended |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime | Limited lifetime | Lifetime on defects; rust not covered | Coating two years, the rest lifetime |
Lodge 12 Inch Cast Iron Skillet: Our First Pick
Basis: materials, as stated by Lodge on its product page: “Made in the USA,” “Seasoned with 100% natural vegetable oil,” and made without PFAS.
The black finish is seasoning, which Lodge describes on its How to Season page as “just oil baked onto the pan through a process called polymerization.” The skillet weighs 7.69 lb as listed with its red silicone handle holder, which Lodge says is “Not intended for use during cooking, grilling, or baking.” Our cast iron skillet comparison goes deeper on this pan against Victoria and FINEX.
Care: Lodge says cast iron left to soak, put in the dishwasher or left to air dry might rust, and that new cast iron is not the best choice for tomato sauce or lemon juice. Once the seasoning is built up, Lodge says you can introduce acidic ingredients with cook times under 45 minutes.
Buy it if you want a seasoned pan that Lodge lists for several heat sources. Skip it if you avoid soy: Lodge’s disclosure lists the seasoning as soybean oil.
Lodge 12 Inch Cast Iron Skillet with Handle Holder on Amazon →
Victoria 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet: The Alternative
Basis: materials, as stated by Victoria on its product page: cast iron preseasoned with flaxseed oil, with “no synthetic coatings, PTFE, or PFOA.”
Victoria says the skillet weighs 6.7 lb, is “Made 100% in Colombia,” and has dual pour spouts and a long curved handle. Its cleaning page says mild dish soap “will not damage your seasoning,” and its first-use page says to dry it completely and “never air dry.”
Buy it if you want flaxseed seasoning or two pour spouts. Skip it if you want a pan made in the USA.
Victoria 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet on Amazon →
All-Clad D3 10 Inch Stainless Fry Pan: Care Text With No Seasoning Step
Basis: materials, as stated by All-Clad on its product page: “two stainless steel layers bonded to a three-layer aluminum and aluminum-alloy core,” with “Double riveted stainless steel handles.”
What touches the food is the stainless layer: All-Clad’s FAQ calls it a “high-quality stainless steel cooking surface.” The aluminum sits in the core, bonded “all the way to the rim.” This listing includes a lid, which the page describes as a “tight fitting matching” lid. The specification lists the material as stainless steel for the two-piece listing and does not name the lid’s knob material. The page does not name a steel grade, so you cannot compare it by the 18/10 or 18/8 numbers that our stainless steel cookware set comparison explains.
Care: All-Clad’s care text for the D3 10 inch fry pan says to preheat “on low to moderate heat” until water “will dance,” add oil, and turn the food when it “no longer sticks to the pan.” To avoid “small white dots or pits,” add salt after liquids boil or food starts to cook. The pan is handwash only, and All-Clad recommends soap and a sponge, and drying immediately.
Buy it if you want a pan whose care text has no seasoning step. Skip it if you want a surface coated for release: All-Clad’s care text says to turn food when it “no longer sticks to the pan.”
All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel 10" Fry Pan with Lid on Amazon →
Made In Carbon Steel Frying Pan: The Lighter Bare-Metal Pan
Basis: materials, as stated by Made In on its product page: “Pre-seasoned with a mixture of shea nut oil and coconut oil,” made in Sweden, with a “separate stainless steel handle.” Its care guide describes the pan body as a “single piece of heavy-duty carbon-iron alloy (99% iron, 1% carbon).” The page lists carbon steel pieces as made without PFAS, PFOA, PTFE, lead, cadmium, aluminum and BPA, and names no handle alloy.
Made In says it stamps the steel into a thin disc “half the weight of cast iron.” The 8 inch pan weighs 2 lbs, with a 5.5 inch cooking surface, and the page lists 8, 10 and 12 inch sizes. It works on gas, electric and induction cooktops and over a campfire, and Made In says it is oven safe.
Care: Made In says to avoid dish soap and the dishwasher because they strip the seasoning, and to clean with a wipe, coarse salt and oil, or boiled water. It recommends against acidic foods such as citrus, wine and vinegar, which it says can strip the seasoning, and suggests its stainless clad pans for those recipes. Dry the pan on the stove to prevent rust.
Buy it if you want cast iron’s seasoned surface in a lighter pan. Skip it if you avoid shea or coconut oil, or do not want to season and dry a pan after every use. Buy it from Made In; we link no store for it.
GreenPan Valencia Pro 12 Inch Frypan: The Ceramic Nonstick Pick
Basis: materials, as stated by GreenPan on its product page: a “Diamond-infused ceramic nonstick coating” on a body “crafted from hard anodized aluminum,” with stainless steel riveted handles, and “PFAS-free nonstick is made without intentionally added PFAS.” GreenPan’s FAQ says the Thermolon coating “starts with a sand derivative.” The page lists the frypan alone, with no lid, at 3.15 lb.
In its California disclosure, GreenPan says the food contact surface of its Thermolon coating “does not contain any of these chemicals,” meaning the intentionally added chemicals on the state’s candidate chemical list. It lists, across its cookware, aluminum, chromium, nickel, iron and manganese as chemicals that may be present in the layers under the coating and in its stainless steel handles, adding that their presence “does not mean that our cookware, bakeware, or appliances will pose a health risk with normal use.”
Care: GreenPan says silicone utensils “will extend the life of your coating,” and its care page says to avoid all oils in spray form, to avoid abrasive detergents and steel wool, and to let the pan cool before washing. The pan is listed as dishwasher safe, but hand washing is recommended.
Buy it if you want a nonstick surface that GreenPan’s own comparison chart says releases food easily with little oil or butter. Skip it if you want a coating warranted beyond two years. For a set instead of one pan, see our Caraway cookware review.
GreenPan Valencia Pro 12" Ceramic Nonstick Frying Pan on Amazon →
How Do You Choose Between Them?
Our suggestions, drawn from the makers’ instructions above:
- You cook acidic food often: stainless; Lodge and Made In both limit acidic food on their seasoned pans.
- You want the least upkeep: stainless or ceramic. Cast iron and carbon steel both need drying and oiling to avoid rust.
- Weight matters: carbon steel, which Made In says is half the weight of cast iron.
- You avoid a seasoning oil: choose stainless or ceramic.
- Size: All-Clad says its 10 inch pan browns two or three chicken breasts at once. The Lodge and GreenPan pans here are 12 inch; Made In sells 8, 10 and 12 inch.
- Induction: Lodge, Victoria, All-Clad, Made In and GreenPan each list induction compatibility.
Coming from conventional nonstick, expect more technique with every metal pan here. Our guides to PFAS-free cookware and to swapping nonstick bakeware for PFAS-free pans cover the rest of the kitchen, and our explainer on what PFAS are and where they hide covers the chemicals. For long tomato braises, our enameled Dutch oven article covers another route.
What Do the Authorities Say?
PFAS in nonstick pans. The FDA says in its Questions and Answers on PFAS in Food: “Some PFAS are approved for use in the manufacture of non-stick cookware coatings.” It adds: “These coatings are made of molecules that are polymerized (i.e., joined together to form large molecules) and applied to the cookware through a heating process that tightly binds the polymer coating to the cookware. Studies show that this coating contains a negligible amount of PFAS capable of migrating to food.” Our suggestion: if you would rather avoid PFAS coatings altogether, the cast iron, carbon steel and stainless pans here have metal cooking surfaces, and GreenPan says its ceramic nonstick is made without intentionally added PFAS.
Lead in cookware. The FDA’s lead in foodwares page says: “There are no FDA regulations that authorize lead for use as a color additive or food additive (including as a component of foodware, cookware, or food contact surfaces).” It also describes a letter telling retailers that certain imported cookware made from aluminum, brass and aluminum alloys known as Hindalium or Indalium has the potential to leach lead into food, and that “such products should not be distributed in the U.S. market.” Our suggestion: check that a pan’s maker states what the cooking surface is made of.
Iron from cast iron. In a study in the Journal of the American Dietetic Association (Brittin and Nossaman, 1986, “Iron content of food cooked in iron utensils”), most of the foods (90%) “contained significantly more iron when cooked in iron utensils than when cooked in non-iron utensils.” Acidity, moisture content, and cooking time of food significantly affected the iron content of food cooked in iron utensils. MedlinePlus says: “Cooking foods in a cast-iron skillet can also help to increase the amount of iron provided.” It also says hemochromatosis, a genetic disorder affecting how the body controls iron absorption, is treated with “a low-iron diet, no iron supplements, and phlebotomy.” Our suggestion: if you have it, ask your doctor before cooking in cast iron.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which of these pans has no seasoning layer or nonstick coating?
Stainless steel: All-Clad calls the D3 a “high-quality stainless steel cooking surface” and its care text has no seasoning step. Cast iron and carbon steel are sold seasoned (Lodge calls seasoning “just oil baked onto the pan”), and GreenPan’s pan has a ceramic nonstick coating.
Is ceramic nonstick PFAS-free?
GreenPan says its Thermolon nonstick is made without intentionally added PFAS.
Can I use soap on cast iron?
Yes, on cast iron: Victoria and Lodge both give soapy-water steps. Made In says to avoid soap on its carbon steel.
Can I cook tomato sauce in these pans?
All-Clad’s pages set no acid limit; Lodge and Made In both limit acidic food on their seasoned pans.
Does cast iron put iron into food?
Yes. Brittin and Nossaman found that most foods had significantly more iron when cooked in iron utensils.
Which pan is best for a first-time cook?
Our suggestion: the Lodge skillet. It arrives seasoned, and Lodge’s care line is three steps: hand wash, dry, oil. Choose the All-Clad if you would rather not manage seasoning.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or any of the makers named here.





