Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or UL Solutions.
For most families the GREENGUARD Gold crib mattress to buy is the DaVinci Complete Slumber: it is near the bottom of the price range, it has no polyurethane foam, it has a waterproof cover, and it weighs about 7 pounds. If price is the whole decision, the Graco Premium Foam costs less and has a zip-off cover you can machine wash, but its core is polyurethane foam. Pay more for the Naturepedic Classic 2-Stage if you want organic cotton, or for a Newton if you want a mattress you can wash down to the core. All six below carry the same GREENGUARD Gold emissions mark, according to their makers, and every crib mattress sold in the US must already pass the federal firmness and fit tests.
The Six Mattresses Compared
| Core | Waterproofing and cover | How you clean it | Sides | Size (in) and weight | Price tier | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Graco Premium Foam | Polyurethane foam | Zip-off polyester cover with a waterproof sleep surface | Machine wash the cover cold, hang to dry | One | 52 x 28 x up to 4.5; about 7 lb | Lowest |
| DaVinci Complete Slumber | Polyester fiber, no polyurethane foam | Waterproof, tear-resistant cover, no vinyl | Wipe the cover | One | 52 x 27.75 x 5; about 7 lb | Low |
| Lullaby Earth Gentle Start | Recycled polyester fiber, no polyurethane foam | Polyethylene waterproof surface under a removable breathable cover | Machine wash the cover, wipe the surface | One | 51.63 x 27.25 x 5; weight not listed | Middle |
| Naturepedic Classic 2-Stage Lightweight | Polyethylene support core under organic cotton fill | Seamless polyethylene waterproofing made from sugarcane, no vinyl | Wipe with a damp cloth and mild soap | Two (infant and toddler) | 51.625 x 27.25 x 6; 11 lb | Upper |
| Newton Original | Wovenaire polymer, 90% air | Not waterproof; zip-off polyester cover over a viscose inner cover | Machine wash the cover; rinse the core in the shower | One firmness for all ages | 52 x 28 x 5.5; 14 lb | Upper |
| Newton Waterproof | Wovenaire polymer, 90% air | Waterproof layer on the toddler side only; infant side water-resistant | Machine wash the cover; rinse the core in the shower | Two (infant and toddler) | 52 x 28 x 5.5; 14 lb | Highest |
Every figure above is from the maker's own product page or label. Current prices are in the product cards below.
Which One to Buy at Your Budget
- Spending as little as possible: the Graco. Its cover unzips and goes in the washing machine, which matters more in the first year than most parents expect. Choose it knowing the core is polyurethane foam.
- Low budget, no foam: the DaVinci. It costs only a little more than the Graco and replaces the foam with polyester fiber. DaVinci does not say its cover comes off, so plan on wiping it down and adding a fitted waterproof protector if you want something you can throw in the wash.
- Middle budget, breathable top: the Lullaby Earth. You get a waterproof surface plus a removable, machine-washable breathable cover on top of it, so most messes go in the wash and the mattress below stays dry.
- Upper budget, organic materials: the Naturepedic. See "Is the organic one worth it?" below before you pay for it.
- Upper budget, washable everything: a Newton. Pick the Original and add a waterproof pad for the baby year, or the Waterproof if you want built-in protection for the toddler and potty-training years.
What Every Crib Mattress Must Already Meet
GREENGUARD Gold is voluntary. The safety baseline is federal law. The CPSC's crib mattress rule (16 CFR part 1241) requires every crib mattress to meet the ASTM F2933 standard, including a sleep surface firmness test, mattress dimensions, seam and coil spring requirements and warning labels. It applies to mattresses made after August 15, 2022, with an updated version for mattresses made after May 3, 2026. The CPSC's crib mattress FAQ says the rule targets "suffocation due to overly soft mattresses" and "entrapment because of poor mattress fits." Mattresses must also pass federal smolder and open-flame tests. Graco's maker, DaVinci, Lullaby Earth and Naturepedic say they meet those without chemical flame retardants; Newton says its viscose inner cover is how it meets them.
Is it firm enough for safe sleep?
Yes: all six are sold as full-size crib mattresses, so each must pass the CPSC firmness test. The AAP's safe sleep guide for parents describes firm as a surface that "shouldn't indent when your baby is lying on it," and NIH's Safe to Sleep campaign says a firm surface "returns to its original shape quickly if pressed on." A crib mattress should feel firmer than you would like for yourself. On the two-sided mattresses, keep the firmer infant side up for the first year: Naturepedic says to flip to the toddler side at about 1 year, and Newton says to wait until year one, or until your baby rolls easily both ways, before using its waterproof side. The Newton Original has one firmness for all ages and never needs flipping.
The rest of safe sleep is about what goes on the mattress. The CPSC's Safe Sleep page says "Bare is Best": nothing in the crib but a fitted sheet, and baby always on their back. The AAP lists mattress toppers among the soft items to keep out.
How to check the fit in your crib
- Confirm it is a full-size crib. The CPSC defines one as 52 3/8 by 28 inches inside, each give or take 5/8 inch. Mini cribs and play yards need their own mattress, and the CPSC says to buy an aftermarket mattress for those only if its label names your crib or play yard model.
- Check the mattress size. The federal rule requires a full-size crib mattress to measure at least 27 1/4 by 51 5/8 inches. All six meet that; the Naturepedic and Lullaby Earth are built close to the minimum, and the Graco and Newtons at the full 52 by 28.
- Push it into one corner. With a sheet on, slide the mattress tight into one corner of the crib and look at the gap at the opposite corner. The federal test allows no more than 3.15 inches there. Newton's everyday version of the check: there should be no gap of more than two fingers between the mattress and the crib sides.
- Use a sheet made for crib mattresses. The AAP says the mattress should be designed for your crib and fit tightly, with a fitted sheet only.
What GREENGUARD Gold Covers, and What It Does Not
GREENGUARD Gold is UL Solutions' certification for low chemical emissions. UL's program page says the Gold tier sets lower VOC emission limits than standard GREENGUARD and is meant for products in nurseries, schools and healthcare settings. Gold products must limit emissions of more than 360 VOCs and total chemical emissions, and must also meet California's CDPH Standard Method for chamber emissions testing (known as Section 01350). The test is on the finished mattress, so it covers the core and the cover together.
What it does not tell you: whether the materials are organic, whether the core is foam, how firm the mattress is or whether it fits your crib. Two mattresses with the same mark can be built very differently, which is why the table above compares cores and covers. For how the mark compares with GOTS organic certification, see our GOTS vs. GREENGUARD Gold comparison; for how the program works, see what GREENGUARD Gold certification means. Each pick's GREENGUARD Gold claim here is read from its maker's own product page, because UL's SPOT directory of certified products would not load for us.
Foam vs. Fiber vs. Organic Cotton vs. Wovenaire
The core decides weight, feel, how you clean the mattress and what it is made of. It does not decide safety: every core has to pass the same CPSC firmness test.
- Polyurethane foam (Graco): light and the least expensive. Storkcraft, which makes the Graco mattress under license, lists the core as 100% polyurethane foam and says it is fiberglass free with no chemical flame retardants. Choose it if price matters most; skip it if you want to avoid polyurethane foam.
- Polyester fiber (DaVinci, Lullaby Earth): layers of dense polyester batting instead of foam, at a low to middle price. DaVinci's label lists resinated polyester fiber batting; Lullaby Earth says its fill is recycled polyester fiber. Both makers say they use no polyurethane foam and no vinyl.
- Organic cotton over a polyethylene core (Naturepedic): the "organic" part is the cotton fabric and fill. The Lightweight model's support core is food-grade polyethylene, with plant-based PLA layers, so it is not foam-free in the strict sense, though it has no polyurethane foam, latex or wool.
- Wovenaire (Newton): a woven food-grade polymer that Newton says is 90% air. It is the only core here you can wash: Newton says to rinse it in the shower with soap and cool water and stand it up to dry. It is also the heaviest at 14 pounds.
Newton and Lullaby Earth also sell their mattresses on breathability, citing their own airflow tests. No federal test rates breathability; the CPSC rule tests firmness and fit.
The Picks
DaVinci Complete Slumber Waterproof Crib & Toddler Mattress
DaVinci lists this mattress (model M5384C) as GREENGUARD Gold certified. Its core is high-density polyester fiber, and DaVinci says the mattress is "free of polyurethane foam, vinyl and chemical flame retardants" and meets the California TB 1633 flammability test without them. The waterproof cover is tear-resistant, and at about 7 pounds it is easy to lift for sheet changes. It measures 52 by 27.75 by 5 inches, has one sleep surface, and carries a 25-year warranty. It is the pick for most nurseries because it gets you a foam-free, waterproof GREENGUARD Gold mattress at close to the lowest price. Its one drawback is the cover: DaVinci does not say it is removable, so it is a wipe-down surface.
See the DaVinci Complete Slumber on Amazon →
Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress
Storkcraft lists the Graco Premium Foam (models 06710-400, -400A and -403) as GREENGUARD Gold Certified. The core is polyurethane foam and the cover is polyester with a waterproof sleep surface. The cover unzips and goes in the washing machine on cold and delicate, then hangs to dry; Storkcraft says not to put it in the dryer. It measures 52 by 28 by up to 4.5 inches, weighs about 7 pounds and has a 10-year limited warranty. It arrives rolled in a box, and Storkcraft says to let it expand for up to 48 hours before use. Buy it if the lowest price and a washable cover matter more to you than avoiding foam.
See the Graco Premium Foam on Amazon →
Lullaby Earth Gentle Start Breathable Crib Mattress
Lullaby Earth says its crib mattresses are GREENGUARD Gold certified for low chemical emissions. The Gentle Start has a recycled polyester fiber fill and a food-grade polyethylene waterproof surface, covered by a removable three-dimensional fabric cover that is machine washable. That layout is the point of this one: spills and diaper leaks land on a cover you can wash, over a surface that keeps them out of the core. Lullaby Earth says it uses no vinyl or PVC, polyurethane foam, phthalates or fiberglass, and no flame retardant chemicals. It measures 27.25 by 51.63 by 5 inches and has a lifetime limited warranty.
See the Lullaby Earth Gentle Start on Amazon →
Naturepedic Classic Organic Crib Mattress, Lightweight 2-Stage
Naturepedic lists the Classic as GREENGUARD Gold certified. The Lightweight 2-Stage (model MC34) has organic cotton fabric and fill over a food-grade polyethylene core, a seamless waterproof surface made from sugarcane-based polyethylene, and no vinyl, polyurethane foam, flame retardants or glues, per Naturepedic. It is 27.25 by 51.625 by 6 inches and weighs 11 pounds. The infant side is firmer; Naturepedic says to flip to the slightly softer toddler side at about 1 year. To clean it, Naturepedic says to wipe the surface with a damp cloth and mild cleanser and let it dry fully before putting a sheet back on. If organic certification is your main reason for buying, our organic crib mattress guide reads Naturepedic's GOTS certificate and compares it with its other organic models.
See the Naturepedic Classic 2-Stage Lightweight on Amazon →
Newton Baby Original Crib Mattress
Newton lists the Original as UL GREENGUARD Gold Certified. Its Wovenaire core is 90% air and 10% food-grade polymer, inside a viscose inner cover and a quilted polyester outer cover. It is the most washable mattress here: the outer cover goes in the machine on cold and delicate and tumble dries on low, and the core rinses clean in the shower. It is not waterproof, so most families add a waterproof pad. It has one firmness for all ages, measures 52 by 28 by 5.5 inches and weighs 14 pounds. The core has a limited lifetime warranty and the covers two years. Newton sells extra covers, which is worth considering if you want a spare ready for night-time accidents.
See the Newton Original on Amazon →
Newton Baby Waterproof Crib Mattress
Newton lists the Waterproof as GREENGUARD Gold Certified too. It has the same core, size and weight as the Original. The difference is the cover: Newton quilts a TPU waterproof layer into the toddler side, under two layers of spacer fabric, and leaves the infant side water-resistant rather than waterproof. Newton recommends sleeping on the infant side until year one, or until your baby rolls easily both ways. So it does not make a waterproof pad unnecessary in the baby year; it is the version to buy if you are planning for the toddler and potty-training years. It is the most expensive pick here.
See the Newton Waterproof on Amazon →
Do You Still Need a Waterproof Pad?
- Graco, DaVinci, Lullaby Earth, Naturepedic: no, for the mattress's sake. Each has a waterproof surface. A pad is a convenience: Naturepedic recommends one so you can wash the pad instead of wiping the mattress at 2 a.m., and it is most useful on the DaVinci and Naturepedic, whose surfaces you can only wipe.
- Newton Original: yes, if you want waterproofing. The mattress breathes and washes but is not waterproof.
- Newton Waterproof: its waterproof side is the toddler side, so in the first year it behaves like the Original. The infant side is water-resistant, and Newton says most baby-year leaks are handled by washing the cover.
If you add a pad, use a thin, fitted waterproof protector sized for a crib mattress, not anything padded. The CPSC warns against supplemental padding in cribs, and the AAP counts mattress toppers among the soft items to keep out. For fitted options, see our comparison of GOTS certified crib mattress pads or our organic waterproof mattress protectors. Whatever the mattress, let it dry fully before the sheet goes back on.
Is the Organic One Worth Several Times the Price?
Only if organic materials are what you want to pay for. The Naturepedic costs several times as much as the Graco or DaVinci, but it does not buy a better emissions result (all six carry GREENGUARD Gold), and it does not buy a firmer or more federally compliant mattress (all six must pass the same CPSC tests). What the extra money does buy: organic cotton fabric and fill, no polyurethane foam, a seamless waterproof surface with heat-sealed edges, and a two-sided design. If those matter to you, it is the one to buy, and our organic guide covers its alternatives. If your goal is a foam-free, waterproof GREENGUARD Gold mattress, the DaVinci gets you there for much less.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is GREENGUARD Gold the same as non-toxic?
No. It means the finished mattress met UL's limits for emissions of more than 360 VOCs and total chemical emissions into the air. It does not certify what the mattress is made of, whether it is organic, or how firm it is.
Is GREENGUARD Gold stricter than standard GREENGUARD?
Yes. UL says the Gold tier sets lower VOC emission limits than standard GREENGUARD and adds the California CDPH chamber test method. It is the tier UL points to for nurseries and schools.
Which side of a two-sided crib mattress goes up?
The firmer infant side, for about the first year. Naturepedic says to flip at about 1 year, and Newton says to wait until year one or until your baby rolls easily in both directions.
Can I use a hand-me-down crib mattress?
Check the manufacture date on its label first. Mattresses made after August 15, 2022 had to meet the CPSC's crib mattress rule, including its firmness test. It should also fit your crib by the corner check above and not be worn or torn.
Do I need a waterproof pad on a waterproof mattress?
Not to protect the mattress. A thin, fitted pad makes cleanup faster because you can wash it instead of wiping the mattress. On a Newton Original, which is not waterproof, add one if you want waterproofing.
The mattress is one part of the crib. To match it with a frame, see our GREENGUARD Gold certified cribs; for what goes on top, our GOTS certified crib sheets. If you have also seen the MADE SAFE mark on a listing, our MADE SAFE crib mattress guide explains what it screens for. Planning the whole nursery? Start with our non-toxic baby registry.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or UL Solutions.







