Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group, GOTS or MADE SAFE®.

For most families the organic crib mattress to buy is the Naturepedic Classic Organic 2-Stage Lightweight. It is the least expensive of the four below, it has a waterproof, wipe-clean surface, it weighs 11 pounds, and Naturepedic's GOTS certificate from Control Union covers its mattresses as "Organic" grade, 100% organic cotton. Pay more for the Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage if you want a removable cover you can machine wash, choose its innerspring version if the mattress will serve more than one child, and choose the Babyletto x Avocado if you want wool and natural latex instead of a polyethylene core and will add a waterproof protector. All four are full-size crib mattresses, and every crib mattress sold in the US must pass the CPSC's firmness and fit rule.

The Four Mattresses Compared

Naturepedic Classic 2-Stage LightweightNaturepedic Breathable 2-Stage LightweightNaturepedic Breathable 2-Stage InnerspringBabyletto x Avocado Dual-Stage
BasisGOTS (Control Union)GOTS (Control Union)GOTS (Control Union)MADE SAFE® (MADE SAFE index)
CorePolyethylene WaveSupport core, organic cotton battingPolyethylene WaveSupport core, organic cotton battingSteel innerspring, organic cotton battingWrapped coils, coconut husk fiber bonded with latex, wool batting
SurfaceWaterproof, wipe cleanWaterproof, plus removable washable coverWaterproof, plus removable washable coverOrganic cotton cover; no waterproof surface listed
Size (maker)27.25 x 51.625 x 6 in27.25 x 51.625 x 6 in27.25 x 51.625 x 6 in28.25 x 52 x 5.5 in
Weight11 lb14 lb19 lb23 lb
Weight limit (maker)80 lb80 lb100 lbNot stated
Latex or woolNeitherNeitherNeitherBoth
Best forMost familiesWashing instead of wipingSeveral childrenNatural-fiber build

All four have a firmer infant side and a softer toddler side. Prices are in the product cards below.

Is It Firm Enough, and Will It Fit My Crib?

Firmness and fit are what the federal rule is about. The CPSC's crib mattress rule (16 CFR part 1241) makes every crib mattress meet ASTM F2933, including a sleep surface firmness test, mattress dimensions, coil spring and seam requirements, and labeling. The CPSC's crib mattress FAQ says the rule targets "suffocation due to overly soft mattresses" and "entrapment because of poor mattress fits," and that all 139 deaths in its final rule are potentially related to compatibility factors "such as firmness, fit, thickness, floor structure." The rule applies to mattresses made after August 15, 2022 (a newer edition of ASTM F2933 applies to those made after May 3, 2026), and the label must show the date of manufacture, so check that date before using a hand-me-down.

The American Academy of Pediatrics asks for "a firm, flat sleep surface," explains that firm "means that it shouldn't indent when your baby is lying on it," and says to make sure the crib mattress "is designed for your specific crib and that it fits tightly." NIH's Safe to Sleep campaign describes firm as a surface that "returns to its original shape quickly if pressed on." The AAP's recommendations apply to babies up to 1 year, which is why each of these mattresses tells you to use the firmer side first. Naturepedic says to flip to its toddler side at about 1 year.

On fit, a full-size crib has an inside of 52 3/8 by 28 inches (each plus or minus 5/8 inch), and the federal rule requires a full-size crib mattress to measure at least 27 1/4 by 51 5/8 inches, with a corner gap of no more than 3.15 inches when the mattress, with a sheet on, is pushed into one corner. All four picks are full-size crib mattresses. The three Naturepedic models are built to that minimum (27.25 by 51.625 inches); the Babyletto is a little larger at 28.25 by 52 inches. Mini and midi cribs, and the smaller stages of some convertible cribs, need their own mattress: Babyletto notes that standard, midi and mini mattresses "are not interchangeable." For anything other than a full-size crib, the CPSC says to buy only a mattress whose label names your crib or play yard model.

Once it is in the crib, the CPSC's safe sleep rule of thumb is "Bare is Best": "nothing but a fitted sheet." The AAP lists mattress toppers among the soft items to keep out of the crib. Fill in the registration card that comes with the mattress; the CPSC requires one on every durable infant product so the maker can reach you about a recall.

Which Pick for Which Family

  • A first baby and a normal budget: the Classic 2-Stage Lightweight. It has everything the Breathable has except the removable cover.
  • You would rather put messes in the washer: the Breathable Lightweight. Its cover zips off for the machine, and the waterproof surface underneath stops leaks reaching the core.
  • The mattress will be handed down to a second child: the Breathable Innerspring. Naturepedic recommends its innerspring "if you plan on using the crib mattress for multiple children," and it carries a 100-pound limit against 80 for the lightweight core.
  • You want wool, coconut fiber and latex instead of polyethylene: the Babyletto x Avocado.
  • Latex allergy in the house: one of the Naturepedic models. Naturepedic lists no latex, wool, coir or soy; the Babyletto uses latex to bond its coconut fiber.

Organic Cotton, Coil or Polymer Core: Which Is Better?

None is better for sleep safety: every core has to pass the same CPSC firmness test. They differ in weight, how you clean them, how long they last and what they contain.

  • Lightweight core (Naturepedic WaveSupport): food-grade polyethylene, wrapped in organic cotton. At 11 to 14 pounds it is the easiest to lift for 2 a.m. sheet changes. Naturepedic calls it a GOTS-allowed accessory material; it is not organic itself.
  • Innerspring: steel coils with a border rod, wrapped in organic cotton. Heavier (19 pounds), with the higher weight rating and Naturepedic's pick for multiple children.
  • Natural fiber hybrid (Babyletto x Avocado): wrapped coils under coconut husk fiber bonded with latex, wool batting and an organic cotton cover. It is the heaviest at 23 pounds.
  • Polymer core (for example Newton's Wovenaire): Newton describes it as "90% air, 10% food-grade material," with no foam, glue, latex or springs, and you can wash the whole mattress. Its cover is polyester and it is not organic, so it is not on this page; our GREENGUARD Gold crib mattress guide compares the Newton models with other low-emission mattresses.

What GOTS, GREENGUARD Gold and MADE SAFE Tell You

  • GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) certifies the textile product and the company making it. The current standard (version 8.1) allows the "Organic" label only when at least 95% of the fiber is certified organic, prohibits polyurethane foam in mattresses, and lists chlorinated, brominated, antimony-based and borate flame retardants as prohibited inputs. It is the only one of the three that tells you the mattress is organic.
  • GREENGUARD Gold is UL Solutions' certification for low chemical emissions into indoor air. It says nothing about whether materials are organic, which is why foam-free polymer mattresses can carry it.
  • MADE SAFE® screens a product's ingredients against its banned list of substances. It does not certify organic content. Our explainer on what MADE SAFE certified means covers its scope, and our MADE SAFE crib mattress guide includes mini and oval sizes this page does not.

Naturepedic's pages list several other marks on these mattresses, including GREENGUARD Gold, MADE SAFE® and EWG VERIFIED®. This guide names one basis for each mattress; for the side-by-side on what GOTS and GREENGUARD Gold each check on nursery bedding, see GOTS vs. GREENGUARD Gold.

Which Flame Retardants and Materials to Avoid, and Who Says So

Every mattress sold in the US has to pass two CPSC flammability standards: a lit-cigarette smoldering test (16 CFR 1632) and a 30-minute open-flame test (16 CFR 1633). That is why conventional mattresses use flame retardant chemicals or barrier layers. Here is what the authorities say about the materials parents ask about:

  • Organohalogen flame retardants: in a 2017 guidance document, the CPSC recommended that makers of children's products and mattresses "refrain from intentionally adding non-polymeric, organohalogen flame retardants," and that consumers, "especially those who are pregnant or with young children," get assurances that products do not contain them. This is guidance, not a ban.
  • PBDEs (a family of brominated flame retardants): the EPA says certain PBDEs are "persistent, bioaccumulative, and toxic," with neurobehavioral effects as its critical human health concern. US manufacture and import of penta- and octaBDE were phased out in 2004, and the main producers of decaBDE committed to end sales by the end of 2013. The EPA notes that PBDE components are still being detected in people and the environment.
  • Polyurethane foam and VOCs: a 2014 study in Environmental Science & Technology ("Infant exposure to emissions of volatile organic compounds from crib mattresses," Boor and colleagues) found that all 20 crib mattresses tested emitted VOCs, new ones more than used ones, and that polyurethane foam released a wider range of VOCs than polyester foam. Concentrations in an infant manikin's breathing zone were 1.8 to 2.4 times those in the room. The authors call infant exposure "possibly elevated"; the study did not measure health effects.
  • Vinyl covers and phthalates: the CPSC's crib mattress FAQ lists its limit of 0.1% for each regulated phthalate in accessible plasticized parts of children's toys and child care articles.

On the picks: GOTS prohibits polyurethane foam in mattresses and bans the flame retardant groups named above. Naturepedic says its crib mattresses are made without flame retardants, fiberglass, polyurethane foam, glues, vinyl/PVC or phthalates, and that they meet federal flammability standards "without the need for added flame retardant chemicals or barriers." Babyletto says its mattress uses wool batting, and that MADE SAFE's screening covers flame retardants and fiberglass.

Waterproof or Not, and Do You Need a Protector?

The three Naturepedic mattresses have a waterproof surface made of polyethylene from non-GMO sugarcane, with heat-sealed seams, and Naturepedic says it is not vinyl or PVC. You wipe it with a damp cloth and mild soap, or 3% hydrogen peroxide or rubbing alcohol to sanitize, and let it dry before putting the sheet on. Naturepedic says you do not need a protector with these mattresses. The Breathable models add a removable cover you machine wash and dry, which is why Amazon lists them "with protector pad."

The Babyletto x Avocado has an organic cotton cover and no waterproof layer on its spec sheet, and Babyletto sells Avocado's waterproof crib protector alongside it. A leak that soaks into wool and coconut fiber is hard to clean, so plan on a protector. Our crib mattress pad comparison covers Naturepedic's and Avocado's organic waterproof pads, and our GOTS certified crib sheets guide covers the fitted sheet that goes on top. The safe sleep guidance above still applies: a fitted pad made for crib mattresses, under a fitted sheet, never a soft topper.

Naturepedic Classic Organic 2-Stage Lightweight: The One to Buy

Naturepedic's GOTS scope certificate from Control Union covers the company's mattresses made of 100% organic cotton fiber, label grade "Organic." Naturepedic describes the Classic as GOTS-certified organic cotton fabric and fill over a lightweight polyethylene core, with a PLA (plant-based) firmness layer and no latex, wool or soy. The 2-stage version flips from an extra-firm infant side to a slightly softer toddler side.

What you give up against the Breathable is the removable cover: the Classic is waterproof and wipe-clean, but nothing comes off for the washer. If you are happy wiping it down and swapping sheets, it does the job for less. Naturepedic also sells a single-stage Classic; the 2-stage is the one linked here.

See the Naturepedic Classic 2-Stage Lightweight on Amazon →

Naturepedic Breathable Organic 2-Stage: For a Washable Cover

The Breathable has the same organic cotton, waterproof surface and 2-stage design as the Classic, under the same Control Union certificate, plus a removable cover that Naturepedic says adds airflow between your baby and the waterproof surface. The cover goes in the washer and dryer, so a blowout means swapping the cover rather than wiping the mattress. Naturepedic suggests keeping a spare cover.

It comes with two cores. The lightweight (14 pounds, 80-pound limit) is the one most families want. The innerspring (19 pounds, 100-pound limit) uses steel coils with an edge rod; Naturepedic recommends it for a mattress that will serve more than one child.

See the Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage Lightweight on Amazon →

See the Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage Innerspring on Amazon →

Babyletto x Avocado Dual-Stage: For Wool and Natural Fibers

MADE SAFE's index lists the Babyletto "Dual-Stage, Organic & Non-Toxic Crib Mattress" as MADE SAFE® certified "in all currently available sizes / varieties," and that listing is this pick's basis. Babyletto describes an organic cotton cover and wool batting over coconut husk fiber, bonded with organic latex, and individually wrapped coils. The infant side is firm and the toddler side softer, and the two are easy to tell apart: white piping on the infant side, terracotta on the toddler side.

Choose it for the natural-fiber build, not for convenience. It is the heaviest of the four at 23 pounds, it has no waterproof surface, and it contains latex. It measures 52 by 28.25 by 5.5 inches, and Babyletto also makes mini and midi versions for its smaller cribs.

See the Babyletto x Avocado Dual-Stage Crib Mattress on Amazon →

Around the Mattress

If you are still choosing the crib itself, our GREENGUARD Gold certified cribs guide covers frames and finishes. When your child moves on, a 2-stage crib mattress usually goes with them into a toddler bed, and our MADE SAFE toddler and kids mattress guide covers the twin-size step after that. For the rest of the nursery list, start with our non-toxic baby registry.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best organic crib mattress?
For most families, the Naturepedic Classic Organic 2-Stage Lightweight: GOTS certified, waterproof, 11 pounds and the least expensive of the four here. The Breathable version adds a washable cover, and the Babyletto x Avocado suits families who want wool and natural latex.

Are organic crib mattresses firm enough for a newborn?
They have to be. Every crib mattress sold in the US must pass the CPSC's firmness test under 16 CFR part 1241. Use the firmer infant side for the first year; the AAP describes firm as a surface that does not indent when your baby lies on it.

Do I need a waterproof protector on an organic crib mattress?
Not on the Naturepedic models, which have a waterproof, wipe-clean surface. The Babyletto x Avocado has no waterproof layer, so add a thin waterproof pad made for crib mattresses under the fitted sheet.

Do these mattresses contain flame retardants?
Naturepedic says its crib mattresses are made without flame retardant chemicals or barriers and meet federal flammability standards without them. GOTS, its basis here, prohibits brominated, chlorinated, antimony and borate flame retardants. Babyletto says MADE SAFE's screening of its mattress covers flame retardants and fiberglass.

Does EWG rate crib mattresses?
EWG has no crib mattress rating database like Skin Deep. Naturepedic lists EWG VERIFIED® on its own crib mattress pages, but this guide uses GOTS and MADE SAFE® as the basis for its picks.

Will a standard crib mattress fit a mini crib?
No. Mini and midi cribs need their own mattress. For any crib that is not full size, the CPSC says to buy a mattress whose label names your crib model.

Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group, GOTS or MADE SAFE®.