Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or UL Solutions.

Five widely sold convertible cribs carry GREENGUARD Gold on their maker's own page for that exact model: the DaVinci Marley 3-in-1, the Babyletto Modo 3-in-1, the Babyletto Lolly 3-in-1, the Storkcraft Santorini 5-in-1 and the Storkcraft Casablanca 5-in-1 with Drawer. The Marley costs the least, the Modo and Lolly come with their toddler conversion kit in the box, the Santorini converts all the way to a full-size bed, and the Casablanca adds a storage drawer for a small nursery. GREENGUARD Gold is a limit on the chemicals a product gives off into indoor air. It is separate from the federal crib safety rule, which every new crib sold in the US must meet, and all five makers say these cribs meet it.

The Five Cribs Compared

DaVinci MarleyBabyletto ModoBabyletto LollyStorkcraft SantoriniStorkcraft Casablanca
BasisGREENGUARD Gold, per DaVinciGREENGUARD Gold, per BabylettoGREENGUARD Gold, per BabylettoGREENGUARD Gold, per StorkcraftGREENGUARD Gold, per Storkcraft
Converts toToddler bed, daybedToddler bed, daybedToddler bed, daybedToddler bed, daybed, full bedToddler bed, daybed, full bed
In the boxCrib only (toddler kit W4099 extra)Crib and toddler kitCrib and toddler kitCrib and toddler guardrail (full-bed hardware extra)Crib, drawer and toddler guardrail (full-bed hardware extra)
FrameSolid New Zealand pineSolid New Zealand pineSolid New Zealand pineSolid New Zealand pineSolid pine, engineered wood and wood composites
Assembled size (L x W x H)53.75 x 29.75 x 35 in53.25 x 30 x 34.75 in53.5 x 29.75 x 35 in54.25 x 29.85 x 35.83 in53.86 x 29.41 x 35.31 in
Weight46 lb60 lb53 lb51.8 lb65.2 lb
Mattress heights44444
StorageNoneNoneNoneNoneTwo-compartment drawer
PriceLowestMiddleMiddleHigherHighest

Sizes, weights and contents are from each maker's product page. Every crib takes a standard full-size crib mattress, sold separately. Current prices are in the product cards below.

Which One to Buy

  • You want the lowest price: the DaVinci Marley. Budget for the toddler conversion kit if you plan to use it, since DaVinci sells it separately.
  • You want everything in one box: the Babyletto Modo or Lolly. Both include the toddler bed kit. Pick on looks: the Modo is plain slats all round, the Lolly has a contrasting frame and tapered wooden legs.
  • You want one piece of furniture until grade school: the Storkcraft Santorini. It is the only solid-pine crib here that becomes a full-size bed, and the toddler guardrail is included.
  • Your nursery has no room for a dresser: the Storkcraft Casablanca. The drawer sits under the mattress, so leave clear floor in front of the crib to pull it out. It is also the heaviest crib here, so build it in the room where it will stay.
  • Your room is tight on width: all five fit in about 30 by 54 1/4 inches of floor, so footprint barely separates them. Weight and the drawer matter more.

What GREENGUARD Gold Covers on a Crib

GREENGUARD Gold is run by UL Solutions under its UL 2818 standard. UL says the Gold level "sets even lower VOC emission limits" than standard GREENGUARD and is aimed at products used in nurseries, schools and healthcare settings, and that certified products are subject to a review of the manufacturing process and routine testing. It measures what a product emits into indoor air: volatile organic compounds such as formaldehyde.

Does it cover the paint and finish? Yes, as emissions. The makers certify the crib itself, so the stain, paint and any glued or composite panels are part of what is measured. That matters most on the Casablanca, which Storkcraft says uses engineered wood and wood composites alongside solid pine. GREENGUARD Gold is not a test for lead in the paint. That is covered separately by federal law: the CPSC's crib rule includes surface coating requirements that apply to every crib, and DaVinci and Babyletto each say their finishes are lead and phthalate safe.

What it does not tell you: whether the wood is organic, how strong the crib is, or anything about the mattress you put in it. A GREENGUARD Gold crib and a GREENGUARD Gold mattress are certified separately. The Environmental Working Group does not rate cribs or nursery furniture, so GREENGUARD Gold is the emissions mark to look for here.

The Five Cribs in Detail

UL's public certification directory blocks automated lookups, so the basis for each crib below is its maker's own product page for that model.

DaVinci Marley 3-in-1: Lowest Price

DaVinci's Marley product page lists the crib (model W4901) as "GREENGUARD Gold Certified" and says it is made of solid New Zealand pinewood. It has four mattress heights, straight slats and playful mid-century legs, and at 46 lb it is the lightest crib here. It converts to a toddler bed and daybed with DaVinci's toddler kit W4099, which is sold separately. The finish shown on Amazon is the one DaVinci calls Honey, a mid-tone wood stain; DaVinci also makes it in Walnut and in two-tone White/Natural, White/Walnut and Light Sage/Honey.

See the DaVinci Marley 3-in-1 on Amazon →

Babyletto Modo 3-in-1: Simplest Design, Kit Included

Babyletto's Modo page says the crib (model M6701) is "screened for harmful chemicals to ensure it meets GREENGUARD GOLD Certification." Slats run all the way round, the frame is solid New Zealand pine, and the toddler bed conversion kit comes in the box. At 60 lb it is a heavy, solid crib for its size. This listing is the White finish.

See the Babyletto Modo 3-in-1 on Amazon →

Babyletto Lolly 3-in-1: Two-Tone Look, Kit Included

The Lolly page calls the crib (model M9001) "GREENGUARD Gold certified." It is the same size and pine construction as the Modo but with spindles, rounded corners and tapered natural-wood feet, and it also includes the toddler bed kit. This listing is the Canyon/Washed Natural finish: a Canyon-colored frame on washed natural legs.

See the Babyletto Lolly 3-in-1 on Amazon →

Storkcraft Santorini 5-in-1: Converts to a Full-Size Bed

Storkcraft's Santorini page lists the crib as "GREENGUARD Gold Certified" and made of solid New Zealand pine, with curved end panels. It converts to a toddler bed, a daybed and a full-size bed with headboard and footboard (two ways). Storkcraft includes a toddler guardrail; the hardware for the full-bed stage is sold separately. This listing is the Hazelnut finish (model 04622-308), a warm mid-brown.

See the Storkcraft Santorini 5-in-1 on Amazon →

Storkcraft Casablanca 5-in-1 with Drawer: Built-In Storage

The Casablanca page lists the crib as "GREENGUARD Gold Certified." Storkcraft describes a full-size drawer with a divider, set under the mattress, which can stand in for a dresser in a small room. Storkcraft says it is built from solid New Zealand pine, engineered wood and wood composites, which is why the emissions mark is worth having on this one. It converts through the same five stages as the Santorini, with the toddler guardrail included and full-bed hardware sold separately. At 65.2 lb it is the heaviest here. This listing is the Frosted Oat finish (model 04622-60D), a light wood tone.

See the Storkcraft Casablanca 5-in-1 with Drawer on Amazon →

The Federal Safety Standard Every Crib Must Meet

Any full-size crib sold in the US must meet the CPSC's mandatory crib rule, 16 CFR part 1219, which adopts the ASTM F1169 standard (currently the F1169-19 version). It covers slat strength and spacing, hardware, mattress support, corner posts, openings, surface coatings and labeling, and the maker must have the crib tested by a third-party lab and issue a Children's Product Certificate. The 2010 final rule, in force since June 28, 2011, prohibits traditional drop-side cribs and applies to used cribs as well as new ones, including those in child care.

For the five cribs here, that means:

  • All five have fixed sides. DaVinci, Babyletto and Storkcraft each say their crib is tested to ASTM and CPSC crib standards.
  • Fill in and mail the registration card in the box (or register on the maker's site). Federal law requires the card so the maker can reach you about a recall.
  • Keep the manual and the leftover hardware. You need both to convert the crib later, and a crib without its instructions is one the American Academy of Pediatrics says not to use.
  • If you are offered a second-hand crib, skip any drop-side model, and check it against CPSC recalls.

How the crib is set up matters as much as which one you buy. The CPSC's safe sleep guidance is "Bare is Best": nothing in the crib but a fitted sheet, with baby always on their back. NIH's Safe to Sleep campaign adds that the sleep surface should be firm, flat and level, and that babies should share a room with a parent, in their own sleep space, for at least the first 6 months. No bumpers, pillows, blankets or toys.

Which Mattress Fits, and How Tight

All five take a standard full-size crib mattress. The CPSC defines a full-size crib's inside as 28 inches (plus or minus 5/8) wide by 52 3/8 inches (plus or minus 5/8) long, and crib mattresses have their own federal rule, 16 CFR part 1241 (ASTM F2933), which includes size and firmness tests. Any new full-size crib mattress sold in the US has to meet it.

The five cribs' assembly manuals set the same limits:

  • Size: at least 27 1/4 by 51 5/8 inches.
  • Thickness: no more than 6 inches. Storkcraft also sets a minimum of 4 inches for its cribs.
  • Gap: no more than 3 cm (about 1 3/16 inches) between the mattress and any side. Push the mattress into one corner and check the gap on the two opposite sides. If it is wider, the mattress is too small for the crib. The AAP's wording is that the mattress should be designed for your crib and fit "tightly."
  • Height: lower the mattress to its lowest position by the time your baby can pull up to stand, and stop using the crib as a crib once your child climbs out or reaches 35 inches tall. Each manual says the same.

If you want the mattress to carry GREENGUARD Gold too, our GREENGUARD Gold crib mattress comparison lists six, with their cores and care. Use a fitted sheet made for a standard crib mattress; our GOTS certified crib sheets page compares four by fit and fabric.

Before and After the Crib

Many families start with a smaller bedside sleep space for the first months; our look at GREENGUARD Gold bassinets covers that stage, including the Storkcraft Santorini and Casablanca bassinets that match the cribs above. When the crib becomes a toddler bed, the GREENGUARD Gold dressers and bookcases that go with it come with their own anchoring rule. For a fuller list of what else to buy, see the non-toxic baby registry checklist, and for how to read the mark itself, our explainer on what GREENGUARD Gold certification means.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which cribs are GREENGUARD Gold certified?
Among widely sold convertible cribs, the DaVinci Marley 3-in-1, Babyletto Modo 3-in-1, Babyletto Lolly 3-in-1, Storkcraft Santorini 5-in-1 and Storkcraft Casablanca 5-in-1 with Drawer are each listed as GREENGUARD Gold certified on their maker's product page for that model.

Does GREENGUARD Gold cover the paint and finish?
It covers what the finished crib emits into the air, paint, stain and composite panels included. It is not a lead test: lead in surface coatings is limited separately by the federal crib rule, 16 CFR part 1219.

What safety standard should any crib meet?
The CPSC's full-size crib rule, 16 CFR part 1219, which adopts ASTM F1169. It has been mandatory since June 28, 2011, bans traditional drop sides and applies to used cribs too.

What size mattress fits these cribs?
A standard full-size crib mattress at least 27 1/4 by 51 5/8 inches and no more than 6 inches thick, leaving no gap over 3 cm (about 1 3/16 inches) at any side. Storkcraft also asks for at least 4 inches of thickness.

If the crib is GREENGUARD Gold, is the mattress too?
No. The crib and mattress are certified separately, so a GREENGUARD Gold mattress has to be chosen on its own.

Does EWG rate cribs?
No. The Environmental Working Group does not rate or certify cribs or other nursery furniture.

Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or UL Solutions.