Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or MADE SAFE®.
Thirteen crib mattresses are listed on the MADE SAFE® registry, from four makers: Naturepedic, Avocado, Babyletto and My Green Mattress. We compare the seven you can buy through the links on this page. For most standard cribs, buy the Naturepedic Classic Organic Lightweight 2-Stage: at 11 pounds it is the lightest standard-size pick here, it has a wipe-clean waterproof surface and a firmer infant side, and it costs the least of the four standard-size options. MADE SAFE screens the materials that go into a mattress. GREENGUARD Gold measures what the finished mattress gives off into the air. Neither one checks firmness or fit; the federal crib mattress standard does that.
The Seven Mattresses Compared
| Mattress | Fits | Inside | Weight | Waterproof surface | Sides | MADE SAFE® entry |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Naturepedic Classic Lightweight 2-Stage | Standard crib; 27.25 x 51.625 x 6 in | Food-grade polyethylene core, organic cotton | 11 lb | Yes, wipe clean; no removable cover | Firm infant side, softer toddler side | Classic Lightweight |
| Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage, Lightweight | Standard crib; 27.25 x 51.625 x 6 in | Food-grade polyethylene core, organic cotton | 14 lb | Yes, under a removable, machine-washable cover | Firm infant side, softer toddler side | Breathable 2-Stage |
| Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage, Innerspring | Standard crib; 27.25 x 51.625 x 6 in | Steel innerspring, organic cotton | 19 lb | Yes, under a removable, machine-washable cover | Firm infant side, softer toddler side | Breathable 2-Stage |
| Babyletto x Avocado Dual-Stage | Standard crib; 52 x 28.25 x 5.5 in | Coconut fiber bonded with organic latex, wool, wrapped coils, organic cotton cover | 23 lb | None listed; add a protector | Firm infant side, softer toddler side | Babyletto Dual-Stage |
| Naturepedic Breathable Mini | Mini crib; 23.5 x 37.5 x 3 in | Food-grade polyethylene core, organic cotton | 8 lb | Yes, under a removable, machine-washable cover | One side | Breathable Mini |
| Babyletto x Avocado Mini | Mini crib; 37.25 x 23.25 x 4.75 in (not midi) | Coconut fiber bonded with organic latex, wool, wrapped coils, organic cotton cover | 14 lb | None listed; add a protector | One side | Babyletto Mini |
| Naturepedic Breathable Oval | Stokke Sleepi V2 (27 x 47 x 3 in) or V3 (27.5 x 53.7 x 3 in) | Lightweight polyethylene core, organic cotton | Not listed | Yes, under a removable, machine-washable cover | One side | Oval |
Sizes, weights and materials are from each maker's product page and law label. Every registry entry above reads "MADE SAFE® Certified in all currently available sizes / varieties." Prices are in the product cards below.
Fit and Firmness: What the Federal Standard Covers
No chemical certification tells you whether a crib mattress is firm enough or fits your crib. A federal rule does. Every new crib mattress sold in the US must meet the CPSC's crib mattress standard, 16 CFR part 1241, which covers full-size, mini and other non-full-size crib mattresses. The CPSC says the rule addresses "suffocation due to overly soft mattresses" and "entrapment because of poor mattress fits." For a full-size crib, the mattress must measure at least 27 1/4 by 51 5/8 inches, and the gap at the corner in the standard's fit test may not exceed 3.15 inches. Both Naturepedic standard models are built to that minimum, and the Babyletto is slightly larger.
- Mini and oval cribs: the CPSC requires a separately sold mattress for a non-full-size crib to carry "test-verified compatible model information." Its consumer advice is plain: if your crib is not named on the label, "do not purchase or use the product." Naturepedic and Babyletto describe their minis as fitting standard mini cribs, so look for your crib's model on the mattress label or packaging before you use it. Babyletto says its mini does not fit midi cribs or its Pogo and Yuzu cribs. Naturepedic's oval names the Stokke Sleepi V2 and V3.
- Firm, flat, fitted sheet only: the American Academy of Pediatrics says a firm surface "shouldn't indent when your baby is lying on it," that the mattress should be "designed for your specific crib" and fit tightly, and to use "a fitted sheet only." It lists mattress toppers among the soft items to keep out of the crib. NIH's Safe to Sleep describes firm as a surface that "returns to its original shape quickly if pressed on."
- Infant side first: on the two-sided mattresses, put the firm side up for a baby. Naturepedic says to flip to the toddler side at about 1 year.
Naturepedic says its crib mattresses meet CPSC and AAP firmness guidance, and Babyletto describes its mini as firm and "aligned with safe sleep guidelines." The standard applies to every mattress here regardless of which chemical label it carries, so a MADE SAFE® listing does not make a mattress firmer, and a cheaper mattress without one is held to the same firmness and fit rules.
How MADE SAFE Differs from GREENGUARD Gold and GOTS
Crib mattress listings often name two or three of these labels, and each answers a different question.
| Label | What it checks | How | What it leaves out |
|---|---|---|---|
| MADE SAFE® | The materials and substances a maker reports, against a Banned / Restricted List that MADE SAFE puts at more than 15,000 substances | Mostly a paper review of maker and supplier disclosures; lab tests in select cases | What the finished mattress emits; anything the maker did not report |
| GREENGUARD Gold | Chemical emissions from the finished product, including limits on more than 360 VOCs | Chamber testing by UL | Which materials are inside; organic content |
| GOTS | Organic fiber content and textile processing | Audits of the supply chain; a mattress may not use polyurethane foam | Emissions; non-textile parts such as coils |
MADE SAFE's certification standard says companies must disclose all known added substances, and that for a mattress the reviewed materials include "the coils, support and comfort layers, top and bottom layers, flame retardants, waterproofing." It calls certification "primarily a paper screening" and says what is not reported "cannot be screened." For how mattress textiles are processed, MADE SAFE defers to GOTS and the organic latex standard GOLS rather than applying its own list. Harmful VOCs are one of the categories it screens for, but on paper, not by measuring the air around a finished mattress.
UL says GREENGUARD Gold limits emissions of more than 360 VOCs and follows California's chamber test method for indoor products. The GOTS standard requires at least 70% certified organic fiber and prohibits polyurethane foam in mattresses. None of the three is run by the Environmental Working Group. For the GOTS and GREENGUARD Gold side by side, see what each of those two labels tests on a crib mattress, and for MADE SAFE across every product type, read what MADE SAFE certified means.
Naturepedic Classic or Breathable?
All three standard-size Naturepedic picks share a size (27.25 by 51.625 by 6 inches), organic cotton fabric and fill, and a seamless waterproof surface Naturepedic makes from sugarcane-based polyethylene. All three have a firmer infant side and a slightly softer toddler side. Naturepedic says it uses no polyurethane foam, flame retardants, fiberglass or glues in them. The differences are the cover and the core.
Classic Lightweight 2-Stage. The plastic-faced mattress is the sleep surface; you wipe it with a damp cloth, mild soap, 3% hydrogen peroxide or rubbing alcohol, and let it dry before putting the sheet back. At 11 pounds it is the easiest to lift at 2 a.m. Naturepedic gives an 80-pound weight limit. It is the cheapest MADE SAFE® standard crib mattress we compared.
See the Naturepedic Classic Lightweight 2-Stage on Amazon →
Breathable 2-Stage, Lightweight. The same waterproof mattress with a removable quilted cover on top that you can machine wash and dry. Naturepedic sells spare covers, so one can be in the wash while the other is on. It weighs 14 pounds, with the same 80-pound limit. Pick it over the Classic if you would rather wash a cover than wipe a surface.
See the Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage Lightweight on Amazon →
Breathable 2-Stage, Innerspring. Steel coils with a border rod in place of the polyethylene core, and a 100-pound limit. Naturepedic recommends it if the mattress will serve more than one child. The cost is weight: 19 pounds.
See the Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage Innerspring on Amazon →
Babyletto x Avocado: No Plastic Layer, More Weight
Avocado makes this mattress for Babyletto. Babyletto describes an organic cotton cover over wool batting, with coconut husk fiber bonded by organic latex and individually wrapped coils for support; the law label lists the fill as 63% coconut fiber and 37% wool. That makes it the pick for parents who want natural fibers and no plastic waterproofing. It also contains latex, which matters if anyone in your home has a latex allergy.
The trade-offs are two. It weighs 23 pounds, double the Naturepedic Classic. And Babyletto lists no waterproof layer, so a leak can reach the wool and coconut fill; Babyletto pairs it with Avocado's waterproof crib protector. If you add one, use a thin protector fitted to the mattress, not a padded topper. Our guide to organic crib mattress pads from Naturepedic and Avocado compares the options. At 52 by 28.25 inches it is slightly larger than the Naturepedics, so buy sheets sized for a standard crib mattress at least 5.5 inches deep.
See the Babyletto x Avocado Dual-Stage on Amazon →
Mini Cribs and the Stokke Sleepi
Naturepedic Breathable Mini. 23.5 by 37.5 by 3 inches and 8 pounds, with the same waterproof surface and washable cover as the full-size Breathable. Naturepedic gives a 60-pound limit and says babies typically use a mini crib until about 12 to 18 months, sometimes longer, and should move on once they can stand or try to climb out.
See the Naturepedic Breathable Mini on Amazon →
Babyletto x Avocado Mini. 37.25 by 23.25 by 4.75 inches and 14 pounds, single-sided, with the same coconut, latex, wool and coil build as the full-size Babyletto and no waterproof layer. Babyletto says it fits standard mini cribs but not midi cribs, and not its own Pogo or Yuzu.
See the Babyletto x Avocado Mini on Amazon →
Naturepedic Breathable Oval. Made for the Stokke Sleepi, in two sizes: V2 (27 by 47 by 3 inches) and V3 (27.5 by 53.7 by 3 inches). The registry entry notes that it "also fits the Stokke Sleepi crib." The link below is for the V3; if your Sleepi is the older V2, buy the V2 size.
See the Naturepedic Breathable Oval (Stokke Sleepi V3) on Amazon →
Is MADE SAFE Worth Paying More Than GREENGUARD Gold Alone?
The GREENGUARD Gold mattresses in our GREENGUARD Gold crib mattress comparison, such as the Graco Premium Foam and the DaVinci Complete Slumber, cost a fraction of anything on this page. Here is what the extra money buys, and what it does not.
- It buys a materials review. MADE SAFE looked at what the maker reported going into the mattress, including the waterproofing and the core, against its banned and restricted list. GREENGUARD Gold does not look at ingredients at all.
- It buys a different build. Naturepedic says its picks use organic cotton and no polyurethane foam or flame retardants, and the Babyletto law label lists only coconut fiber and wool over a coil unit. The Graco Premium Foam, by contrast, has a 100% polyurethane foam core, per its maker.
- It does not buy a firmer or better-fitting mattress. Every new crib mattress, cheap or not, must pass the same federal firmness and fit tests.
- It does not measure emissions. If low emissions from the finished mattress are your main concern, a GREENGUARD Gold listing answers that directly.
If what goes into the mattress matters to you, the Naturepedic Classic Lightweight 2-Stage is the least expensive way to get a MADE SAFE® listing on a standard crib mattress. If your priority is a firm, well-fitting mattress at the lowest cost, a GREENGUARD Gold-only mattress does that job. For a wider look at organic options compared by core and cover, see our organic crib mattress guide.
The Other MADE SAFE Crib Mattresses
The registry also lists Naturepedic's Breathable Ultra, Ultimate Infant + Toddler and Element (a buybuy BABY model), Avocado's Organic, Eco and Luxury crib mattresses, and My Green Mattress's Emily Organic Crib Mattress. We have no matched Amazon listing for those, so they have no product card here. For bedding to go with any of these, compare MADE SAFE certified crib sheets from Babyletto, Naturepedic and Avocado. When your child moves out of the crib, our guide to MADE SAFE certified toddler and kids mattresses covers the next step, including the My Green Mattress Pure Eco kids mattress.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which crib mattresses are MADE SAFE certified?
The MADE SAFE® registry lists 13 crib mattress entries: seven from Naturepedic (Classic Lightweight, Breathable 2-Stage, Breathable Ultra, Breathable Mini, Oval, Ultimate and Element), three from Avocado (Organic, Eco and Luxury), two from Babyletto (Dual-Stage and Mini) and one from My Green Mattress (Emily). Each entry covers all currently available sizes and varieties of that model.
Is MADE SAFE the same as GREENGUARD Gold or GOTS?
No. MADE SAFE reviews the materials a maker reports against its banned and restricted list. GREENGUARD Gold measures chemical emissions from the finished mattress in a test chamber. GOTS certifies organic fiber content and textile processing, and bans polyurethane foam in mattresses.
Does a MADE SAFE certified crib mattress meet the federal safety standard?
Every new crib mattress sold in the US must meet the CPSC's crib mattress standard (16 CFR part 1241), which tests firmness and fit; that requirement is separate from MADE SAFE, which does not test either. For a mini or oval crib, the CPSC says the mattress label must name your crib model.
Which MADE SAFE crib mattresses are waterproof?
All five Naturepedic picks have a seamless waterproof surface; the Breathable models add a removable, washable cover on top. The two Babyletto x Avocado mattresses list no waterproof layer, so pair them with a thin fitted waterproof protector.
Which is the lightest for sheet changes?
For a standard crib, the Naturepedic Classic Lightweight 2-Stage at 11 pounds, then the Breathable Lightweight at 14 and the Breathable Innerspring at 19. The Babyletto x Avocado Dual-Stage is the heaviest at 23 pounds. For a mini crib, the Naturepedic Breathable Mini weighs 8 pounds and the Babyletto Mini 14.
Is a MADE SAFE crib mattress worth the extra cost over a GREENGUARD Gold one?
It is if you care what materials are inside: you get a materials review and, in these models, organic cotton and no polyurethane foam. It is not if you are paying for sleep safety, because every new crib mattress must meet the same firmness and fit standard. The Naturepedic Classic Lightweight 2-Stage is the least expensive way to get the MADE SAFE listing.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or MADE SAFE®.





