Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS).
All four GOTS certified crib sheets below fit a standard 28 x 52 inch crib mattress, and each maker prints a GOTS label or license number on the product itself. Choose by mattress depth and fabric. For most cribs we would buy the Babyletto organic muslin sheet: it carries a full GOTS label (Control Union CU 1127841) and its deep pocket covers any full-size crib mattress. Pick Burt's Bees Baby jersey for a mattress 5.5 inches deep or less, Makemake Organics for a smooth sateen feel, and Little Unicorn for muslin sized to a 6-inch mattress. Buy two or three, and put nothing else in the crib.
The four sheets compared
| Sheet | Fabric | Mattress fit (maker) | GOTS label on the product | Care (maker) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Babyletto organic muslin | Muslin (open, gauzy weave) | 52 x 28 in; sheet 8.75 in deep | Organic, Control Union CU 1127841 | Wash cold; hang or tumble dry low |
| Burt's Bees Baby organic fitted sheet | Jersey knit | 28 x 52 x 5.5 in | Organic, Control Union CU 831717 | Wash cold, gentle; tumble dry low |
| Makemake Organics (Safari or Blossom) | 300-thread-count sateen, pre-washed | 28 x 52 in; mattresses up to 9 in deep | GOTS-26390 | Wash warm, gentle; tumble dry low |
| Little Unicorn organic muslin | Muslin | 52 x 28 x 6 in | Organic, certified by OTCO, GOTS-10212 | Wash cold; tumble dry low; no bleach |
Current prices for each sheet are in the product cards on this page.
Which one to buy
- You have a standard 6-inch crib mattress, or you add a waterproof pad under the sheet: Babyletto. Its 8.75-inch pocket has room for both, and muslin is the most breathable of the four fabrics.
- Your mattress is 5 to 5.5 inches deep: Burt's Bees Baby. Its pocket matches that depth exactly, and the jersey stretches over the corners. On a full 6-inch mattress it will be tight, so measure first.
- You want a sheet that feels like grown-up bedding: Makemake sateen. It is the smoothest of the four and has the deepest pocket, up to 9 inches.
- You want muslin with a pocket cut for a 6-inch mattress: Little Unicorn. Its stated size matches the federal maximum thickness for a full-size crib mattress.
- Your nursery runs warm: either muslin sheet. It runs cool: Burt's Bees Baby jersey, which the maker describes as warmer to the touch than woven sheets.
How tight a crib sheet should fit, and why
Tight enough that the elastic sits under all four corners of the mattress and the top lies flat, with no slack you can pull up into a fold. A sheet that is too shallow can pop off a corner; one that is too deep can bunch. Either leaves loose fabric in the crib.
Loose fabric is the reason fit matters. NIH's Safe to Sleep campaign says a baby's sleep surface should be firm, flat, level "and covered only with a fitted sheet," and lists non-fitted sheets among the items that can pose dangers in a sleep area. The CPSC's safe sleep page puts it as "Bare is Best": nothing but a fitted sheet in a crib, bassinet or play yard. The American Academy of Pediatrics says to use "a fitted sheet only," to make sure the mattress fits the crib tightly, and to keep pillows, blankets, bumpers and non-fitted sheets out of the crib.
The numbers a sheet has to match come from the federal crib rule. The CPSC says a full-size crib's interior is 28 inches (plus or minus 5/8) by 52 3/8 inches (plus or minus 5/8), and that the mattress must be at least 27 1/4 by 51 1/4 inches and no thicker than 6 inches. So every "standard" crib sheet is cut for roughly 28 by 52 inches; the real difference between brands is pocket depth.
To check the fit at home:
- Measure the mattress height, adding a waterproof pad if you use one.
- Put the sheet on and tug each corner. The elastic should stay hooked under the mattress.
- Recheck after the first few washes, since cotton tightens slightly as it shrinks.
If you do add a waterproof pad, use a fitted one made for crib mattresses; our comparison of GOTS certified crib mattress pads covers two. For the mattress itself, our organic crib mattress guide lists each model's depth.
Percale, jersey, muslin or sateen: what changes for a baby
All four are 100% cotton, so the difference is how the fabric is made and how it feels and breathes, not what it is made of.
- Muslin is a loose, gauzy weave. Naturepedic, which sells both muslin and sateen crib sheets, says muslin's "open weave allows more airflow" and is the better choice "if temperature regulation is your top priority." Babyletto says its muslin softens with every wash.
- Jersey is a knit, like a T-shirt. It stretches, which makes it easy to pull over corners, and Burt's Bees Baby says its jersey sheets are "warmer to the touch than woven sheets." GOTS allows knits a little more shrinkage than wovens (see the FAQ below).
- Sateen is woven with more yarn on the surface. Naturepedic describes it as "smooth, soft, and slightly silky," softer and more drapey than percale. Makemake's is 300 thread count.
- Percale is a plain weave that Naturepedic describes as "cool, crisp." None of our four picks is percale; Coyuchi sells an organic crinkled percale crib sheet it describes as GOTS certified, if you prefer that feel.
For a baby, warmth matters more than texture. NIH Safe to Sleep warns that overheating raises the risk of SIDS, and the AAP says to dress a baby in no more than one layer more than an adult would wear. In a warm room, choose muslin; in a cool room, adjust the baby's clothing or use a wearable blanket rather than adding bedding.
How many crib sheets you need
Two or three. Naturepedic recommends having "at least two or three on hand," one on the crib, one in the wash and one ready for middle-of-the-night changes. Night-time leaks and spit-up usually mean a change before the laundry is done, so a third sheet saves a 2 a.m. dryer run. Burt's Bees Baby also sells some of its organic crib sheets as a set of two on its own site.
1. Babyletto Organic Muslin Crib Sheet
Babyletto shows the full GOTS label on its product page: the GOTS logo, the grade "Organic" and the Control Union license CU 1127841. The sheet is 100% organic cotton muslin, made in China, and Babyletto lists it at 52 x 28 x 8.75 inches, designed for "a 360 degree fit on a U.S. standard crib / toddler bed mattress." That deep pocket is why it is our pick for most cribs: it fits any legal full-size mattress with room for a fitted waterproof pad. Wash cold and hang or tumble dry low.
It comes in a long list of prints and solids, and Babyletto sells the same muslin sheet in mini-crib and bassinet sizes on its own site. If you also want a sheet listed by MADE SAFE, our MADE SAFE crib sheet comparison covers which Babyletto colors that listing names.
See the Babyletto organic muslin crib sheet on Amazon.
2. Burt's Bees Baby Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet
Burt's Bees Baby's crib sheet pages carry the GOTS logo with "organic certified by CU 831717" (Control Union). The sheet is 100% organic cotton jersey, made in India, with elastic all the way around and extra fabric on the bottom edge to keep it from creeping up. Burt's Bees Baby sizes it for a 28 x 52 x 5.5-inch crib or toddler mattress, the shallowest pocket here, so it suits thinner mattresses best. Machine wash cold on gentle, use only non-chlorine bleach, and tumble dry low.
See the Burt's Bees Baby organic fitted crib sheet on Amazon.
3. Makemake Organics Fitted Crib Sheet, Safari or Blossom
Makemake's Safari and Blossom pages both say the sheet is made at a GOTS certified factory in India and give the certification number GOTS-26390. It is 300-thread-count organic cotton sateen, pre-washed, 28 x 52 inches with elastic all around, for mattresses up to 9 inches deep. The two prints are the same sheet. On Makemake's own store each comes with a matching pillowcase; keep the pillowcase out of a baby's crib.
Makemake's care instructions are a warm, gentle wash, non-chlorine bleach only, and a low tumble dry with prompt removal.
See the Makemake Safari crib sheet on Amazon or the Blossom print.
4. Little Unicorn Organic Cotton Muslin Crib Sheet
Little Unicorn's product page shows the GOTS logo with "organic, certified by OTCO, GOTS-10212." The sheet is 100% organic cotton muslin, sized for a standard 52 x 28 x 6-inch crib mattress, so it suits the common 6-inch mattress without the spare depth of the Babyletto. Machine wash cold, tumble dry low, and skip bleach and the iron. Make sure you pick an "Organic Cotton Muslin" print: Little Unicorn also sells a plain cotton muslin crib sheet that is not GOTS labeled.
See the Little Unicorn organic muslin crib sheet on Amazon.
What the GOTS label on a crib sheet tells you
Under the current GOTS standard (version 8.1), a GOTS label must show three things beside the logo: the label grade, the certification body and the certified company's certification number. "Organic" means at least 95% certified organic fiber; "made with organic materials" means at least 70%. GOTS also limits the chemical inputs used in processing, sets residue limits for finished goods, and requires baby textiles to pass a saliva colorfastness test. What it does not do is rate fit, so the depth checks above still apply. GOTS's online supplier directory would not load for us, so the license numbers here are as each maker prints them on its product.
GOTS is about organic fiber and how it was processed. OEKO-TEX Standard 100 is a test of the finished fabric for specified substances and does not require organic cotton; our OEKO-TEX crib sheet guide covers that label. For a fuller walk through the GOTS grades, see what GOTS certified organic textiles means. To finish the crib with GOTS sleepwear, our GOTS baby pajamas guide also explains the flame-retardant rules for children's sleepwear.
Frequently asked questions
Will a GOTS organic crib sheet shrink?
A little. GOTS requires finished goods to stay within 3% of their size after five washes for woven fabric (muslin, sateen, percale) and within 5% for knits such as jersey. On a 52-inch sheet that is about 1.5 inches for a woven and about 2.5 inches for a knit. Makemake pre-washes its sateen, and all four makers say to tumble dry on low, which helps.
Do these sheets fit a mini crib or a bassinet?
No. All four are sized for a full-size crib mattress. A mini crib or bassinet needs a sheet made for that mattress. Babyletto sells its GOTS muslin sheet in mini and bassinet sizes, and Burt's Bees Baby sells organic bassinet sheets.
Makemake's sheet comes with a pillowcase. Can I use it?
Not in a baby's crib. The AAP and NIH Safe to Sleep say to keep pillows out of a baby's sleep area, so set the pillowcase aside for later.
Is GOTS the same as OEKO-TEX Standard 100?
No. GOTS follows certified organic fiber through processing and limits the chemicals used along the way. OEKO-TEX Standard 100 tests a finished textile against limits for specified substances and does not require organic cotton. A sheet can carry one, both or neither.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS).






