This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or MADE SAFE®.

If someone told you to look for a made safe certified crib sheet, you have probably noticed the search is harder than it sounds. We checked the MADE SAFE® registry and Amazon listings, and one crib sheet cleared both: Babyletto’s organic muslin sheet. This page covers what that certification means, which colors the registry lists, and what to check before you buy.

Short Answer: One MADE SAFE Certified Crib Sheet We Could Verify

The Babyletto Organic Muslin Crib Sheet has a product entry on the MADE SAFE® registry, and the Beach Bum color we link below is among the colors that entry names. It was in stock on Amazon when we checked on October 17, 2026. We did not find a second MADE SAFE® crib sheet that we could both confirm in the registry and buy from a working Amazon listing, so this is a one-product page rather than a ranked list.

What MADE SAFE Certifies, and What It Doesn’t

MADE SAFE® is a nonprofit certification program. It screens a product’s materials and ingredients against its lists of banned and restricted substances. If a component fails the screen, the product does not qualify.

It is not an emissions test on the finished sheet. It is not a sleep-safety standard, and it is not a guarantee about how any one baby will respond to a product. For the longer explanation, read our guide to what MADE SAFE certified means. MADE SAFE® is a separate organization from EWG, and we are not affiliated with either one. See our MADE SAFE Certified Changing Pad Cover: Babyletto Quilted Muslin Spotlight. See our MADE SAFE Certified Swaddle Blanket: Babyletto Muslin Swaddle Spotlight.

The Babyletto Organic Muslin Crib Sheet

This is a fitted muslin crib sheet from Babyletto. The registry entry is titled “Babyletto Muslin Crib Sheet” and states that it is MADE SAFE® certified in all currently available sizes and in these colors: Beach Bum, Burnt Sienna, Daisy, Dew Drop, Golden Hour, Matcha, Oat Stripe, Ocean Waves, Olive Branches, Plain White, Rainbow, Terrazzo, and Women in History.

Certification basis: MADE SAFE®
Color we link: Beach Bum
Registry entry: verify on the MADE SAFE registry
Price when checked: $48.00 · ASIN: B0CYH9CM2T (in stock)

Babyletto Organic Muslin Crib Sheet, Beach Bum, on Amazon →

If you prefer another color, make sure it is one of the colors listed above before you order. A different Babyletto print that is not on the registry list is not covered by what we say here.

Why There Is Only One Pick

This was the only MADE SAFE® crib sheet we could match to a working Amazon listing. We would rather show one verified product than pad the page. If you are open to other certifications, we have separate guides to GOTS certified crib sheets and OEKO-TEX certified crib sheets. Shopping for the mattress too? See our MADE SAFE certified crib mattress guide.

What to Check on Any Crib Sheet Label

  • Search the maker and the exact product name on the MADE SAFE® registry, then match the color or print.
  • Confirm the size fits your mattress. Fit is a separate question from certification.
  • Read the care label. Washing guidance varies by fabric.
  • Treat any listing claim you cannot match to a registry entry as unverified.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is MADE SAFE the same as EWG VERIFIED®?
No. They are run by different organizations with different standards, and EWG VERIFIED® does not apply to this product. We are not affiliated with either one.

Does MADE SAFE mean a crib sheet is safe for my baby?
No. The mark means the materials were screened against MADE SAFE®’s lists. It is not a safety guarantee, and we make no health or safety claims about any product.

Are all Babyletto colors MADE SAFE certified?
Only the colors named on the registry entry. Check that your color appears there before you buy.

How do I check a crib sheet listing?
Look up the brand and product on the MADE SAFE® registry and compare the product name, sizes and colors to the listing you are viewing.

This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Certification information comes from the MADE SAFE® public registry. Status, price and stock can change, so verify before purchase.