Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS).

For a GOTS certified baby blanket, buy by job. To swaddle a newborn, the Under the Nile Muslin Swaddle is a 47-inch square of organic cotton muslin, and Under the Nile prints GOTS license ICEA-TX-3555 on its certifications page. For the stroller, car seat and supervised floor time, and later the toddler bed, MakeMake Organics sells a 30 x 40 inch knit in scalloped or pointelle patterns, made from GOTS certified organic cotton yarn under certification number GOTS-26390. One rule comes before any fabric choice: NIH's Safe to Sleep campaign, the American Academy of Pediatrics and the CPSC all say no loose blanket belongs in a baby's crib before the first birthday.

Can a Blanket Go in the Crib?

Not until your baby turns 1. NIH's Safe to Sleep campaign says a crib with nothing in it but a fitted sheet "is the safest option for baby," and lists blankets "under or on top of baby" and "tucked-in blankets" among the things to keep out. It adds that sleeping under blankets and other soft coverings raises the risk of sleep-related death from suffocation and strangulation, and its FAQ says to follow safe sleep recommendations until the first birthday. The CPSC says the same: "Don't add pillows or blankets to your baby's sleep space," and do not use weighted blankets or weighted swaddles.

Organic fiber does not change any of this. A GOTS label is about how the cotton was grown and processed, not how a blanket behaves in a crib. Under Safe to Sleep's bare-crib advice, the one textile left in the crib is a fitted sheet; our GOTS certified crib sheet guide covers those.

To keep a baby warm at night, the AAP's safe sleep guidance says to use layers of clothing or a wearable blanket, and to dress your baby in "only one layer more than you're wearing," because overheating can increase the risk of SIDS. Both brands here sell a muslin wearable blanket on their own sites: Under the Nile's muslin sleep sack (0 to 6 and 6 to 12 months) and MakeMake's wearable blanket (3 to 24 months), which MakeMake says is made at its GOTS-certified factory. For organic sleepers to layer under them, see our GOTS certified baby pajamas.

The Three Blankets Compared

Under the Nile Muslin SwaddleMakeMake Scalloped KnitMakeMake Pointelle Knit
GOTS number (as the maker prints it)ICEA-TX-3555 (certifier ICEA)GOTS-26390GOTS-26390
FabricSingle-layer organic Egyptian cotton muslinThick-spun organic cotton knit, scalloped edgeSame knit, openwork pointelle pattern
Size47 x 47 in30 x 40 in30 x 40 in
Best useSwaddling a newborn; nursing or stroller coverStroller, over car seat straps, supervised floor time, toddler bedSame as scalloped
Care (per the maker)Machine wash warm with like colors, tumble dry low, no bleachGentle cycle, no chlorine bleach, tumble dry lowSame, and the pointelle page adds cold water

Which One to Buy

  • You plan to swaddle: the Under the Nile muslin. A 47-inch square is large enough to wrap a newborn with room to tuck; a 30 x 40 knit is smaller and stretchier.
  • You want one blanket for walks, car rides and the play mat: a MakeMake knit. It is warmer than muslin and small enough to tuck around a stroller seat.
  • You are shopping for a toddler bed: a MakeMake knit, which is sized for it and outlasts the swaddling months.
  • You want a different certification basis: the Babyletto muslin swaddle and the Babyletto muslin quilt rest on MADE SAFE rather than GOTS.

Under the Nile Muslin Swaddle: For Swaddling

Under the Nile's certifications page lists its GOTS license as ICEA-TX-3555, issued by the Italian certifier ICEA, and says its goods are made at its own factory in Egypt, which is inspected each year. The GOTS certificate PDF linked from that page is an older one that has since expired, so the license number printed on the page is the one to go by. The product page describes the swaddle as lightweight, breathable organic Egyptian cotton muslin, 47 x 47 inches, and suggests it for swaddling, as a stroller blanket or as a nursing cover.

How you swaddle matters more than the fabric. The AAP's swaddling guidance says to place a swaddled baby only on its back, to stop swaddling "as soon as your baby shows any signs of trying to roll over" (some babies try as early as 2 months), and to keep the wrap loose at the hips, with room for two or three fingers between the chest and the swaddle. It also warns that a swaddle that comes unwrapped is a loose blanket that could cover your baby's face. Safe to Sleep adds that weighted swaddles are not recommended.

See the Under the Nile muslin swaddle on Amazon

MakeMake Organics Knit Blankets: For Outings and the Toddler Years

MakeMake's product pages for both knits say the same thing: "100% GOTS certified organic cotton yarn," made at a GOTS-certified factory in India, "GOTS certification number GOTS-26390." Its certifications page gives the same number for the company. Both blankets are 30 x 40 inches and knit from thickly spun yarn, which makes them noticeably warmer than a single layer of muslin.

MakeMake's pages give the scalloped and pointelle versions the same yarn, size and certification number; what you see is the difference: scalloped has a wavy edge, pointelle has small openwork holes through the knit. If you are choosing between them, choose on looks and color.

Use a knit blanket where you can see your baby: over a stroller, on the floor for awake tummy time, or over a buckled car seat harness. The AAP's car seat advice is to drape a blanket over the straps once your child is buckled in, not under them, because bulk under the harness keeps it from fitting snugly. After the first birthday, the same blanket fits a crib or toddler bed.

See the MakeMake scalloped knit blanket on Amazon

See the MakeMake pointelle knit blanket on Amazon

Muslin, Knit or Wool: Which Weight for Which Use

  • Muslin is a loose, open cotton weave. One layer is light and breathable and large squares wrap well, so it suits swaddling and warm-weather covering. Both wearable blankets mentioned above are muslin; MakeMake's is three layers.
  • Cotton knit is heavier and stretchier. It is the better choice for cool-weather outings and for a toddler bed, and it is sold as a blanket, not a swaddle.
  • Wool is the cold-weather option. GOTS certifies organic wool as well as cotton, but neither brand's online store lists a wool product, so there is no GOTS wool pick on this page. A wool blanket follows the same rule: outside the crib for the first year.

How to Tell a GOTS Claim Is Real

The GOTS standard (version 8.1) spells out what a genuine label carries:

  • The GOTS logo and a label grade. "Organic" means at least 95% certified organic fiber. "Made with X% organic materials" means at least 70%.
  • The certification body that audited the company, such as ICEA.
  • The certification number of the certified company. Newer numbers follow a GOTS-12345 format, like MakeMake's; older ones carry the certifier's prefix, like Under the Nile's ICEA-TX-3555.

GOTS also says a retail product can mention GOTS only if the finished product is certified and correctly labeled. A listing that says "organic cotton" or "GOTS fabric" with no certifier and no number is not a GOTS label claim. With a number in hand, search the company name in the GOTS certified suppliers directory; its record pages would not open from our connection, so the two numbers on this page are as each maker prints them.

What the label covers: GOTS follows certified organic fiber through spinning, knitting, dyeing and sewing, and restricts the chemicals used along the way. It also sets limit values for chemical residues in finished GOTS goods, including formaldehyde and flame retardants, and requires each certified company to test on a documented risk assessment. Baby textiles must pass a saliva colorfastness test. GOTS is not a crib safety standard. For how it differs from a finished-product test label, see our explainers on what GOTS certification means and what OEKO-TEX Standard 100 means.

How Many You Need, and How to Wash Them

If you plan to swaddle, three or four muslin swaddles is a working number: one in use, one in the wash and spares for spit-up and the diaper bag. Swaddling ends once your baby starts to roll, usually within the first few months, so more than that tends to go unused. One knit blanket covers walks and car rides; a second is handy if you want one kept in the car.

The two fabrics wash differently. Under the Nile's swaddle page says to machine wash warm with like colors, tumble dry on low heat and not bleach, and to always follow the garment label. MakeMake's knit pages say to machine wash on a gentle cycle, use no chlorine bleach, tumble dry on low and take the blanket out promptly; the pointelle page also says to use cold water. GOTS requires every labeled consumer product to pass a dimensional stability test after five washes, which caps shrinkage at 5% for knits and 3% for woven fabrics such as muslin.

If you are building a full list, our non-toxic baby registry covers the rest of the nursery, and our GOTS certified baby gifts pairs well with a blanket for a shower gift. Replacing blankets you already own? Our blanket swap guide walks through it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my baby sleep with a GOTS certified blanket?
Not before the first birthday. NIH's Safe to Sleep campaign, the AAP and the CPSC all say to keep blankets out of a baby's sleep space, whatever the fabric. Use a swaddle on a back-sleeping newborn until signs of rolling, then a sleep sack that leaves the arms free.

When should I stop swaddling?
The AAP says to stop as soon as your baby shows any sign of trying to roll over, which can be as early as 2 months. Safe to Sleep says rolling usually starts around 3 months. After that, switch to a wearable blanket that does not swaddle.

How do I check that a GOTS claim is real?
Look for the GOTS logo with a label grade ("organic" or "made with X% organic materials"), the certification body and a certification number, as GOTS requires. Then search the company in the GOTS certified suppliers directory. "Organic cotton" with no number is a marketing claim, not a GOTS label.

Is GOTS the same as OEKO-TEX Standard 100?
No. GOTS follows certified organic fiber through processing and sets limits on chemical inputs and residues in finished goods. OEKO-TEX describes Standard 100 as a label for textiles tested for harmful substances, from yarn to finished product; organic cotton has its own, separate OEKO-TEX label.

How many swaddles and blankets does a newborn need?
Three or four muslin swaddles if you plan to swaddle, so one can be in use, one in the wash and the rest on hand for spit-up. One knit blanket covers stroller and car outings; swaddling usually ends within the first few months, so do not overbuy swaddles.

How do I wash an organic cotton knit blanket?
MakeMake's product pages say to machine wash on a gentle cycle, use no chlorine bleach, tumble dry on low and take the blanket out promptly; its pointelle page also says cold water. Under the Nile's swaddle page says machine wash warm with like colors, tumble dry low, no bleach. GOTS requires labeled goods to pass a shrinkage test after five washes: within 5% for knits and 3% for woven fabrics such as muslin.

Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS).