Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or the USDA.
For the best organic chocolate to buy or give, pick Alter Eco Classic Blackout 85% if you want the least sugar and the lowest cost per bar, Taza Deliciously Dark 70% if you want a stone-ground bar with a dairy-free, soy-free, vegan statement on the maker’s page, and Theo Pure 70% if you want a single bar to try. All three are dark chocolate with three or four plain organic ingredients, and all three state USDA Organic on the maker’s own pages.
“Organic” tells you how the cacao and sugar were grown and handled. It does not tell you how sweet or how dark the bar is, so the cacao percentage and the Nutrition Facts line for added sugar are what to compare.
How the Three Bars Compare
Every figure below is from the maker’s own page and Nutrition Facts panel. Serving sizes differ, so the sugar column is per the serving each maker lists.
| Bar | Cacao | Added sugar per serving | Allergens stated by the maker | Price band | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alter Eco Classic Blackout | 85% | 4 g (serving size “About 4” per the maker’s panel; about 2.5 servings a bar) | May contain milk, hazelnuts, almonds, coconut and soy | Lowest per bar | Dark chocolate fans, bulk gifts |
| Taza Deliciously Dark | 70% | 11 g (serving: half a 2.5 oz bar, 35 g) | May contain traces of tree nuts and sesame seeds; says dairy free and soy free | Middle | Vegan and dairy-free givers |
| Theo Pure 70% | 70% | 9 g (serving: one third of a 3 oz bar) | Made on equipment that also processes milk, wheat and tree nuts; facility handles peanuts, eggs and sesame | Highest per bar, sold singly | One bar, a taste test |
Price per bar for each pack is in the product details further down.
What Does “Organic Chocolate” Mean?
The USDA’s organic labeling page says organic products must be overseen by a USDA-authorized certifying agent, produced without excluded methods such as genetic engineering, and made using allowed substances. A product labeled “organic” contains at least 95 percent organic ingredients (excluding salt and water), and the seal may appear on it. On these bars that is easy to see: every ingredient of Alter Eco Classic Blackout is marked organic, and so is every ingredient of Taza and Theo.
What the seal does not do is set a sugar limit or rate a bar’s nutrition. For the full explainer, see what the USDA Organic seal means and how to check it.
Each maker states its organic status on its own pages:
- Alter Eco: its certifications page says “Alter Eco is certified Organic by QAI for all products sold in the USA and Canada,” and that the USDA Organic seal appears on its packaging.
- Taza: the Deliciously Dark page says “This product is certified USDA Organic,” and Taza’s FAQ page says “Taza Chocolate is Certified Organic by Baystate Organic Certifiers.”
- Theo: the product page shows the USDA Organic logo, and its certifications page says “Learn more about QAI, our organic certifier.”
Which Bar for Which Taste?
Taza describes 70% as “enough cacao to taste bright and fruity, enough organic cane sugar to keep it friendly.” Alter Eco’s 85% is the darkest of the three, and its 4 g of added sugar per serving is the lowest of the three.
- You like it bitter: Alter Eco at 85%. Its maker describes it as “a seriously dark bar for those who are serious about chocolate.”
- You want dark but friendlier: Taza or Theo at 70%. Taza says it grinds its cacao on granite millstones and does less refining on purpose, so the bar has a gritty texture. Theo describes notes of walnut, prune and a hint of brown spice.
- Your giftee has never had dark chocolate: start at 70% and leave the 85% bar for a confirmed dark chocolate fan. These are dark bars, not milk chocolate.
Dairy-Free, Vegan and Allergens
Ingredient lists are short. Alter Eco lists organic cacao beans, organic raw cane sugar, organic cocoa butter and organic vanilla beans. Taza lists organic cacao beans, organic cane sugar and organic cocoa butter. Theo lists cocoa beans, cane sugar and cocoa butter, each marked organic.
- Dairy free and soy free: Taza states both, plus vegan, on its page. Theo’s page shows vegan and soy free icons. Alter Eco’s icons list vegan and no soy ingredients.
- Cross-contact: each maker adds a statement; the table gives the wording and the paragraph below says what it means for each allergy.
Taza’s FAQ says it makes its chocolate “on machines that are not shared with these ingredients, in a facility that does not process these ingredients” (dairy, casein, whey, soy, eggs), so Taza is the bar to consider for a milk or soy allergy. Taza’s FAQ also says “All products manufactured by Taza Chocolate may contain traces of tree nuts and sesame seeds,” so for a tree nut or sesame allergy skip all three. Alter Eco says it may contain milk and soy, and Theo says its equipment also processes milk. The FDA’s food allergy page says “may contain” style advisory statements are not required by law, so a missing one is not a guarantee either.
Fair Trade and Direct Trade Claims
Alter Eco says it holds Fair for Life Fair Trade certification through Ecocert. Taza says it was “the first U.S. chocolate maker to establish a third-party certified Direct Trade Cacao program” and publishes its numbers in an annual report. Theo marks its ingredients with a fair trade symbol on the product page. These are separate from the USDA Organic seal.
How Much Added Sugar Is in a Bar?
The AAP’s HealthyChildren.org guidance says to aim for less than 25 grams (about 6 teaspoons) of added sugar per day for children 2 years of age and older, and to avoid serving foods and drinks with added sugar to children under 2.
Against that 25 g figure, one Alter Eco serving is about 16%, one Theo serving about 36% and one Taza serving (half a bar) about 44%. Whole bars add up faster. From the makers’ panels, a whole Taza bar is two servings, so 22 g of added sugar, and a whole Theo bar is three servings, so 27 g. Alter Eco’s panel shows 11 g of total sugars for a whole pack (about 2.5 servings) and 22% of the daily value for added sugars. Cane sugar is the second ingredient in all three, and the Added Sugars line counts it whether or not the box says organic.
Who Should Skip These
- Children under 2: see the sugar section.
- Anyone with a tree nut or sesame allergy: skip all three. Peanut allergy: Theo’s page says its facility handles peanuts; Alter Eco’s and Taza’s pages do not mention peanuts, so check the package. Milk or soy allergy: Alter Eco says it may contain milk and soy; Theo says its equipment also processes milk; Taza says its facility does not process dairy or soy.
- Dog owners: keep every bar out of reach. The FDA’s page Leave Chocolate Out of Rover’s Celebrations says “Chocolate is toxic to dogs” and that the darker the chocolate, the more theobromine it contains.
- Anyone who wants milk chocolate: these are dark bars. For a milder candy, our USDA Organic Halloween candy picks include sweeter candy.
Heavy Metals in Chocolate
The FDA’s Closer to Zero page says heavy metals like arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury “may occur in the environment naturally” and from human activities, and can be present where food is grown, raised or processed. That applies to foods in general, and the organic seal describes how ingredients are grown and handled, not a heavy metal result. In its answer to whether organic baby food is safer from heavy metals, which concerns foods for babies and young children, the FDA says: “Not necessarily. Organic crops absorb heavy metals from the earth just like conventional crops do.” The page also says the important thing is to eat a variety of foods that contain different nutrients.
The 3 Picks
1. Alter Eco Classic Blackout 85% Dark Chocolate, 12 Bars: Least Sugar, Lowest Cost per Bar
A bar of 85% cacao. Alter Eco’s page shows 190 calories and 4 g of added sugar per serving. The box of 12 works as a stack of small gifts or a pantry supply for someone who eats a square a day. Alter Eco sells a single bar and a 24-bar case on its own site too; the Amazon listing below is the 12-bar box.
Alter Eco Classic Blackout 85% Dark Chocolate, 12 Bars, on Amazon →
2. Taza Organic Deliciously Dark 70%, 10 Bars: Dairy-Free, Soy-Free, Vegan
A stone-ground 70% bar of organic cacao beans, cane sugar and cocoa butter. Taza’s page shows 190 calories, 6 g of fiber and 11 g of added sugars per half-bar serving (35 g). The 10-bar case suits a group gift or a season of teacher gifts, one bar each.
Taza Organic Deliciously Dark 70% Chocolate Bars, 10 Count, on Amazon →
3. Theo Pure Organic Dark Chocolate 70%, Single 3 oz Bar: One Bar to Try
One 3 oz bar for a single stocking. Theo’s page shows 170 calories, 3 g of fiber and 9 g of added sugars per one-third-bar serving (28 g), and describes organic Congolese beans with notes of walnut, prune and a hint of brown spice.
Theo Pure Organic Dark Chocolate Bar, 70% Cacao, 1 Bar, on Amazon →
How Should You Store Chocolate?
Taza says on its FAQ page: “Chocolate is heat sensitive. The best spot to store chocolate is in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and strong ambient smells. A sealable bag in a cool cupboard or pantry is your best bet if storing for a longer time period. If stored in the refrigerator or freezer, chocolate may pick up smells, experience condensation, or become ‘bloomed’ (brittle in texture and covered with chalky white splotches).”
Stocking and Teacher-Gift Pairings
- Stocking for an adult: one Taza or Alter Eco bar with a small organic tea from our organic stocking stuffers under $25.
- Teacher gift: one Taza or Theo bar tucked into a card with a mug or tea. Check the class’s allergy list first, because each of these bars carries a cross-contact statement.
- Bigger gift set: the Alter Eco box of 12 splits across several gifts. For other ideas, see our EWG VERIFIED® stocking stuffers and our gift guide, or the Holiday Edition guide.
- For a child: a sweeter treat is an easier fit, such as Annie’s Organic Chocolate Chip Cookie Bites, and our guide to organic kids’ snacks covers more.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best organic chocolate?
Alter Eco Classic Blackout 85% for the least added sugar and lowest cost per bar, Taza Deliciously Dark 70% for a dairy-free, soy-free, vegan statement, and Theo Pure 70% for a single bar.
Is organic chocolate lower in sugar than regular chocolate?
Not by rule. The USDA organic standard covers how ingredients are grown and handled and sets no sugar limit. Compare the Added Sugars line on the panel.
Is organic dark chocolate vegan?
Taza states vegan on its page, and Alter Eco and Theo show a vegan icon.
Do these bars contain nuts?
No nuts are in the ingredient lists, but each maker adds a tree nut cross-contact statement, so skip all three for a tree nut allergy.
How much added sugar can a child have?
The AAP says to aim for less than 25 grams (about 6 teaspoons) of added sugar a day for children 2 and older and to avoid added sugar for children under 2. Half a Taza bar has 11 g.
Is the organic label a test for heavy metals?
No. FDA’s Closer to Zero page says organic crops absorb heavy metals from the earth just like conventional crops do.
Which is the best value for a group gift?
The Alter Eco 12-bar box works out lowest per bar of the three and splits across several stockings. Theo is sold as a single bar, so it suits one stocking. Taza’s 10-count case sits between them.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or the USDA.



