This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) earns commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with the Environmental Working Group.

Choosing the healthiest Halloween candy is harder than the label claims suggest. Most conventional candy bags rely on high-fructose corn syrup, synthetic dyes like Red 40 and Yellow 5, and artificial flavors. The Environmental Working Group (EWG), an independent nonprofit, maintains the EWG Food Scores database at ewg.org/foodscores, a resource that rates thousands of packaged foods on three factors: nutrition quality, ingredient concerns, and degree of processing. The five brands below are listed in EWG's Food Scores database and use organic, simpler ingredient lists. NonToxicFinder is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Environmental Working Group.

How EWG Food Scores Rates Halloween Candy

EWG Food Scores is separate from EWG Skin Deep (which rates personal care products) and distinct from the EWG VERIFIED® program (which covers personal care and cleaning products only). There is no EWG VERIFIED® designation for food products. For candy, EWG Food Scores evaluates products on three dimensions:

  • Nutrition: Added sugars, sodium, and overall nutritional profile. Candy always carries added sugar, but products without high-fructose corn syrup, artificial sweeteners, or excess sodium score better in this dimension.
  • Ingredient concerns: EWG reviews ingredient lists for synthetic dyes, artificial flavors, and other additives they flag as concerns at certain exposure levels. Shorter, organic ingredient lists score better.
  • Degree of processing: More heavily processed products score lower. Simpler formulas (organic cane sugar, organic fruit juice for color, real fruit pectin) perform better.

EWG Food Scores uses a 1 (best) to 10 (worst) scale, with lower scores indicating fewer concerns by EWG's criteria. To verify the current score for a specific product or SKU, search at ewg.org/foodscores directly. Scores can differ by flavor variant and package size, and EWG updates ratings on a rolling basis. EWG's ratings are not a food safety certification. The FDA governs food safety in the United States.

Top Picks: Healthiest Halloween Candy Listed in EWG Food Scores

1. YumEarth Organic Halloween Gummy Fruits (20 Snack Packs): Best Value Per Piece

Price: ~$10.39 for 20 individually wrapped 0.5oz snack packs (about $0.52 per pack)

EWG Status: Listed in the EWG Food Scores database. The YumEarth brand is confirmed in the database at ewg.org/foodscores (UPC 810165016835 for this product variant). Verify the current score at ewg.org/foodscores before citing it.

YumEarth Organic Gummy Fruits are individually wrapped at 0.5oz each, practical for trick-or-treat bags without the bulk of full-size candy. Made with organic cane sugar, organic tapioca syrup, and natural fruit flavors with no high-fructose corn syrup, no artificial dyes, and no synthetic flavors. USDA Organic certified. At 20 packs for $10.39, the per-piece cost is lower than most organic candy alternatives, making these a strong lead pick for high-volume trick-or-treating nights.

Shop YumEarth Gummy Fruits on Amazon →

2. YumEarth Organic Halloween Lollipops (60 Count): Best for Volume Giveaways

Price: ~$9.88 for 60 lollipops (about $0.16 per pop)

EWG Status: YumEarth brand is confirmed in the EWG Food Scores database. The Halloween lollipop SKU (B0D1SDCXDL) is a newer listing; verify its specific entry at ewg.org/foodscores/brands/14947-YumEarth/ before citing a score. If no exact SKU match is found, brand-level framing applies: YumEarth products are listed in the EWG Food Scores database.

Sixty lollipops for under $10 makes this the most cost-efficient pick for households expecting many trick-or-treaters. YumEarth lollipops use organic ingredients and real fruit flavor extracts with no artificial colors, no synthetic flavors, and no high-fructose corn syrup. Each pop is individually wrapped and kid-sized. At roughly $0.16 per piece, the per-unit price is competitive with conventional mass-market candy.

Shop YumEarth Lollipops on Amazon →

3. UNREAL Halloween Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups (40 Count, 2 Boxes): Best Chocolate Pick

Price: ~$39.99 for 40 individually wrapped cups in Halloween packaging (about $1.00 per cup)

EWG Status: Listed in the EWG Food Scores database. The Unreal brand appears at ewg.org/foodscores; verify the specific Halloween-edition UPC or packaging variant before citing a score, as multi-pack Halloween editions may carry a different UPC than the standard product listing.

UNREAL reformulates conventional candy to remove corn syrup, artificial colors, and hydrogenated oils. Their dark chocolate peanut butter cups use fair-trade chocolate and no artificial ingredients. The Halloween-edition set comes in two boxes of 20 cups each, individually wrapped for trick-or-treating. At $1.00 per cup, this is a premium pick, best suited for households choosing quality over quantity, or for parents filling a family candy bowl rather than running a high-volume giveaway.

Shop UNREAL Dark Chocolate PB Cups on Amazon →

4. Black Forest USDA Organic Gummy Bears (65 Individually Wrapped Pouches): Best Mid-Range Gummy Option

Price: ~$17.49 for 65 pouches at 0.8oz each (about $0.27 per pouch)

EWG Status: Black Forest Organic Gummy Bears are listed in the EWG Food Scores database. The 65-pouch Amazon bulk pack (B06Y6485FQ) is a seasonal assembly; the underlying product (UPC 041420212949) has a confirmed database entry. Verify the per-bag UPC match at ewg.org/foodscores if citing a specific score, as the pack-size UPC may differ from the single-bag listing.

Black Forest Organic Gummy Bears use USDA Organic-certified ingredients, real fruit juice for color and flavor, and no high-fructose corn syrup, no artificial colors, and no artificial flavors. The 65-pouch format at 0.8oz each is well-sized for trick-or-treat bags. At about $0.27 per pouch, this is a practical mid-range choice for households that want organic gummies without the premium price of chocolate products.

Shop Black Forest Organic Gummy Bears on Amazon →

5. JUSTIN'S Organic Mini Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups (6-Pack of 4.7oz Bags): Best for the Family Candy Bowl

Price: ~$49.99 for a 6-pack of 4.7oz bags (about $8.33 per bag)

EWG Status: Listed in the EWG Food Scores database. The per-bag product corresponds to UPC 840379102024 in the EWG database. Verify the current score at ewg.org/foodscores; the 6-pack bundle groups multiple bags, so check the single-bag listing for the EWG database match.

Justin's mini peanut butter cups use USDA Organic certified chocolate and peanut butter filling with no hydrogenated oils and no artificial ingredients. The 4.7oz bags work well as refillable household candy bowls during the Halloween season rather than individual trick-or-treat handouts. At $8.33 per bag, this is the most expensive per-ounce pick on the list, but the ingredient quality reflects it. A reasonable choice if you want organic peanut butter cups for family use through October.

Shop JUSTIN'S Organic PB Cups on Amazon →

Organic vs. a Strong EWG Food Score: What to Know

USDA Organic certification and a strong EWG Food Score are related but distinct. Organic certification covers how ingredients were grown, not what additives were included afterward. An organic candy can still contain added concentrates, processing aids, or heavily processed ingredients that lower its EWG Food Score. The brands above were selected specifically because they appear in the EWG Food Scores database and use simpler ingredient lists compared to conventional Halloween candy.

Pricing context: organic Halloween candy costs more per piece than conventional options. The picks above range from $0.16 per lollipop (YumEarth) to $1.00 per chocolate peanut butter cup (UNREAL). For households doing large-volume trick-or-treating, the lollipops and gummy bears are the cost-efficient entry points. For quality-focused family use or smaller giveaways, the chocolate peanut butter cups from UNREAL and Justin's make more sense.

For more on how EWG evaluates packaged food, see our guide to the best organic baby food rated by EWG Food Scores The same database and rating methodology applied to infant and toddler food categories.

Completing your Halloween plans? See our non-toxic Halloween face paint guide for picks informed by EWG's research on face paint ingredients, including concerns around heavy metals and synthetic dyes documented in conventional products.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does EWG rate Halloween candy specifically?
The EWG Food Scores database (ewg.org/foodscores) rates packaged candy across categories including gummies, chocolate bars, lollipops, and fruit snacks. EWG Food Scores is separate from EWG Skin Deep (personal care ratings) and from the EWG VERIFIED® program, which applies to personal care and cleaning products only, not food. Search for specific brands and products directly at ewg.org/foodscores.

What does a good EWG Food Score mean for candy?
EWG Food Scores uses a 1-to-10 scale, with 1 being the best rating and 10 the worst. For candy, products score better when they use organic ingredients, avoid synthetic dyes and artificial flavors, and have simpler ingredient lists without high-fructose corn syrup or hydrogenated oils. A lower score reflects EWG's assessment of fewer ingredient concerns and lower processing. It is not a food safety certification by the FDA or any government agency.

Is organic Halloween candy worth the cost for trick-or-treating?
The cost depends on volume and product type. YumEarth lollipops run about $0.16 each and gummy fruit packs about $0.52 per pouch, competitive with premium conventional candy. Chocolate peanut butter cups from UNREAL and Justin's cost more per piece and are better suited to home candy bowls than large-volume giveaways. Whether the cost fits your household depends on your expected trick-or-treat traffic and priorities.

Can I find the specific EWG Food Score for these products?
Specific numeric scores for each product SKU are available at ewg.org/foodscores. We do not cite scores directly because ratings can vary by package size, flavor variant, and UPC, and EWG updates them on a rolling basis. Always check the current score for the exact product you plan to purchase using the product's UPC barcode to find the precise match in the database.

Are there any EWG VERIFIED® Halloween candies?
No. EWG VERIFIED® is a certification program for personal care products and home cleaning products, not food. Candy brands are evaluated in the EWG Food Scores database, which is a separate system with different criteria. No Halloween candy brand carries or should be described as carrying the EWG VERIFIED® mark. See our Santa Cruz Organic Applesauce: What the USDA Organic Seal Covers (Not an EWG Claim).

EWG (ewg.org) is an independent nonprofit. NonToxicFinder is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Environmental Working Group. EWG Food Scores ratings reflect EWG's own analytical methodology and are not a government food safety determination. Verify any product's current EWG Food Score at ewg.org/foodscores before purchasing.