Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or any certification program.

Buy the Zojirushi 16 oz Stainless Mug if you want the maker to say something about the lid, stopper and gasket: its FAQ says “Lids, stoppers, and gaskets are also BPA-free.” It does not name the plastic. Buy the Thermos Stainless King 16 oz if you want a mug its maker lists as dishwasher safe; the Thermos product page, FAQ and care guide name no material for its lid or gasket.

Which Travel Mug Should I Buy?

  • You want to know what touches the drink, lid included: Zojirushi SM-KHE48.
  • You want a mug you can put in the dishwasher: Thermos Stainless King 16 oz, top rack.
  • A stocking or teacher gift: Our suggestion: either mug works. For more gift ideas, see our certified teacher gift picks and organic stocking stuffers.
  • Skip both if you want a ceramic-lined mug, skip the Thermos if a child will carry it, since its guide says “NOT RECOMMENDED FOR USE BY CHILDREN,” and skip the Zojirushi if you often fill it with milk drinks, since Zojirushi advises against dairy.

How Do the Two Mugs Compare?

Zojirushi SM-KHE48Thermos Stainless King Mug
Size16 oz (0.48 liter)16 oz (475 ml)
Body18/8 stainless steel18/8 stainless steel
Interior“non-coated on the inside” (SlickSteel finish, FAQ)“No interior coating” (FAQ)
LidFlip-open; BPA-free per FAQDrinkLock sealing lid; material not named
GasketBPA-free per FAQGasket present; material not named
HandleProduct page lists none“Sturdy handle”
DishwasherNo, all componentsTop rack; hand wash recommended
Warranty5-year, vacuum heat retention5-year, stainless steel vacuumware

What Is the Zojirushi SM-KHE48 Made Of?

Zojirushi’s product page describes a “Durable and sanitary 18/8 stainless steel interior” and lists the 16 oz mug as “Made of BPA-free plastic and 18/8 stainless steel.” It has a “tight fitted flip-open lid” with a “Safety lock to prevent the lid from opening accidentally.”

  • Body and interior: Zojirushi’s FAQ says the SlickSteel finish is “an alternative to our nonstick coating” and is “non-coated on the inside,” using “an electrically charged polishing process” instead.
  • Lid, stopper and gasket: the BPA-free FAQ says “All Zojirushi vacuum bottles and mugs are made of high quality 18/8 stainless steel and BPA-free plastic. Lids, stoppers, and gaskets are also BPA-free.” It does not name the plastic.
  • Prop 65: the product page carries “CALIFORNIA WARNING: Cancer and Reproductive Harm - www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.” and does not say which part it refers to.

Care. The FAQ says “The vacuum insulated mugs or bottles and all their components are not dishwasher safe,” and recommends handwashing with mild dishwashing liquid. It says “It is not recommended to fill the vacuum mug with any type of beverage containing dairy or carbonated drinks,” because dairy “can cause curdling and leave residual odors.” Black dots on rubber gaskets “are mold, which is very difficult to remove,” and Zojirushi recommends replacing the part; the product page lists a lid cover gasket and a stopper gasket as replacement parts. Zojirushi gives a heat figure of “187°F @ 1 hr. / 154°F @ 6 hrs.” for water starting at 203°F.

Warranty. The product page says “Zojirushi 5-Year Warranty on Stainless Steel Vacuum Heat Retention.” It lists Thailand as the country of origin.

What Is the Thermos Stainless King 16 oz Mug Made Of?

Thermos’s product page says “18/8 stainless steel construction” and lists “Durable stainless steel interior and exterior.” It also lists a “Sturdy handle,” a built-in tea hook, and a “DrinkLock™ sealing lid” that “is leak-proof when closed and properly assembled.”

  • Interior: Thermos’s FAQ says “No, Thermos brand stainless steel products have no interior coating.”
  • Lid and gaskets: the Care and Use guide lists a lid, retainer, retainer gasket, sealing disk and main gasket, and the product page, FAQ and care guide name no material for any of them.

Care. The product page says “Dishwasher safe (top rack).” The guide says “This product is top-rack dishwasher safe; however, washing by hand is recommended as the dishwasher uses harsher detergents and hot water that may affect the appearance of your product.” It adds “DO NOT use bleach or cleaners containing chlorine on any parts of the product” and “DO NOT use to store or carry carbonated drinks or dry ice.” It also says “Contents should not be left in the container for longer than 24 hours.” On carrying, the guide says “DO NOT place product in a bag, backpack or other container in which product may shift from an upright position.” Thermos says the mug keeps drinks hot for up to 7 hours and cold for up to 18 hours.

Warranty. Thermos’s warranty page lists 5 years for stainless steel vacuumware and says “This limited warranty is for products purchased in the USA and/or Canada.”

Is There a Ceramic-Lined Option?

Not in these makers’ mug collections. No product title or description in Zojirushi’s Vacuum Insulated Mugs & Bottles collection (39 products) or Thermos’s Mugs & Tumblers collection (29 products) mentions ceramic. Zojirushi and Thermos each say the interior of their stainless mugs is not coated.

What Does Each Maker Say About Lead?

For how insulated bottles are sealed, see our guide to kids’ water bottles and lunch gear.

  • Thermos: its FAQ answers “Are Thermos products lead-free?” with “Thermos products are tested rigorously by independent testing labs. As a result of this testing, we can assure you that Thermos products do not pose a risk of lead exposure to consumers.” This is a general lead statement, not an answer about the vacuum seal, and it names no lab, test or date. the product page, FAQ and care guide do not say how the vacuum is sealed.
  • Zojirushi: its product page and mug FAQ do not mention lead or how the vacuum is sealed.

The FDA’s page on lead in foodware says “There are no FDA regulations that authorize lead for use as a color additive or food additive (including as a component of foodware, cookware, or food contact surfaces).” Our suggestion: if the base of any insulated mug cracks or a base cover comes off, stop using it.

How Do I Choose Between Them?

  • Size: both are 16 oz. Thermos says its mug “Fits most standard car cup holders.”
  • Dishwasher: only the Thermos mug is listed as dishwasher safe.
  • Milk drinks and tea: Zojirushi advises against dairy; Thermos has a built-in tea hook.
  • Carrying it in a bag: Thermos’s guide advises against it.
  • Children: Thermos says “NOT RECOMMENDED FOR USE BY CHILDREN: Keep out of the reach of children, especially when product contains hot contents, which may burn or scald user.” If you carry a baby, the American Academy of Pediatrics says “Avoid carrying your baby and hot liquids like coffee, tea or soup at the same time.” See its burn prevention page.

Why Is the Hydro Flask Mug Not a Pick Here?

Hydro Flask’s product page calls its mug a “12 oz stainless steel insulated mug” and lists “Durable stainless steel,” and it names no material for the interior, lid or gasket. Its FAQ asks “Does Hydro Flask use lead for sealing its bottles and tumblers?” and answers “No.” The question names bottles and tumblers, not mugs.

Our Picks

See the Zojirushi 16 oz Stainless Mug SM-KHE48 on Amazon →

See the Thermos Stainless King 16 oz Mug on Amazon →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best non toxic travel coffee mug?
Of these two, the Zojirushi SM-KHE48 is the one whose FAQ says its lids, stoppers and gaskets are BPA-free. The Thermos mug is the one listed as dishwasher safe.

Is there a ceramic travel mug here?
No. No ceramic mug appears in the Zojirushi or Thermos mug collections.

Can I put them in the dishwasher?
Thermos lists its mug as top rack dishwasher safe; Zojirushi says its mugs and all their components are not.

Are the lids BPA-free?
Zojirushi says so for its lids, stoppers and gaskets. Thermos’s product page, FAQ and care guide name no lid material for this mug.

What do the makers say about lead?
Thermos gives a general assurance for its products; Zojirushi’s product page and FAQ do not mention it.

Can I use them for milk or tea?
Zojirushi advises against dairy; Thermos advises against carbonated drinks and has a built-in tea hook.

Can a child use one?
Thermos says the mug is “NOT RECOMMENDED FOR USE BY CHILDREN.”

What are the warranties?
Zojirushi says 5-year on vacuum heat retention; Thermos lists 5 years for stainless steel vacuumware.

This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or any certification program.