Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or any certification program.
For most homes, buy Meliora Laundry Powder, Unscented, which carries MADE SAFE® certification. Choose AspenClean Unscented Laundry Pods if you want a pre-measured pod with enzymes, and Pure Natural Free & Clear if you want a pump liquid. “Unscented” and “fragrance-free” are not the same label, and EPA explains the difference in its own words below.
Which Fragrance Free Laundry Detergent Should I Buy?
- Most households, HE or standard machine: Meliora Laundry Powder, Unscented.
- You want no measuring and a pod with enzymes: AspenClean Unscented Laundry Pods.
- You want a liquid you can pump or rub into stains: Pure Natural Free & Clear.
- Skip the powder if your washer manual says to use liquid detergent only. Read AAP’s single-load packet advice below before choosing pods.
How Do the Three Compare?
| Meliora Powder, Unscented | AspenClean Pods, Unscented | Pure Natural Free & Clear | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Format | Powder | Pods, 36 per package | Liquid, pump bottle and refills |
| Basis | MADE SAFE® registry | EWG VERIFIED®, per AspenClean | MADE SAFE® registry |
| Loads per package | 128 HE or 64 standard | 36 pods; one pod per load, two for large or soiled loads | No load count on Pure Natural’s pages |
| Dose | 1/2 tablespoon HE, 1 tablespoon standard | One pod, into the drum | 4 pumps, 6 to 7 for larger or soiled loads |
| Enzymes in ingredient list | No | Yes: four | Not stated |
| Water temperature | At least 60°F | Any, per AspenClean | Not stated |
What Is the Difference Between Unscented and Fragrance-Free?
EPA’s Safer Choice program defines both words in its fragrance-free criteria: “Unscented generally means that, while fragrance materials are not used to impart a scent, a product may contain chemicals that neutralize or mask the odors of other ingredients. Fragrance-free means that neither fragrance materials nor masking scents are used in the product.” The same Safer Choice Criteria for Fragrance-free Products document adds that products that qualify for its fragrance-free certification “may still have an odor,” because “Some product ingredients, such as surfactants or solvents, carry an odor.”
FDA’s page Fragrances in Cosmetics covers products regulated as cosmetics, not laundry detergent, but it makes the same point about the word: “Even some products labeled “unscented” may contain fragrance ingredients.”
The practical check is the ingredient list. Meliora’s Unscented list names no scent ingredient, and its ingredients page says “You’ll never see the word “fragrance” in our ingredient lists.” Pure Natural describes its detergent as “not scented but may have a natural fragrance” and as “free from all dyes and perfumes.” AspenClean’s page calls its pods “fragrance-free,” says they contain “absolutely NO synthetic fragrances,” and also says they leave “a gentle, soothing scent.” Our guide to synthetic fragrance covers the ingredient in more depth.
Meliora Laundry Powder, Unscented
Basis: MADE SAFE® certified. The MADE SAFE registry entry for Meliora Laundry Powder reads “MADE SAFE® Certified in all currently available sizes / packaging options, as well as the following scents,” and Unscented is one of the six listed.
What is in it. Meliora’s product page lists the Unscented formula as “Sodium bicarbonate (baking soda), sodium carbonate (washing soda), vegetable soap [sodium cocoate, glycerin, organic cocos nucifera (coconut) oil, water].” No enzyme appears in that list. The page says the product “Contains 128 HE (64 Standard) loads.”
How to use it. “Use 1/2 tablespoon for HE washers and 1 tablespoon for standard washers,” Meliora says to “place directly in the drum beneath clothes, not in the dispensing drawer.” Its FAQ says the powder “requires water to be at least 60 degrees Fahrenheit,” that the “cold” cycle on most modern machines reaches that, and that a “tap cold” setting may not, so it suggests a warmer setting in cold weather. In humid air the FAQ says powder clumping “will not hinder the effectiveness at all.”
Babies and sensitive skin. Meliora’s FAQ says its products are “designed to be gentle enough for those with sensitive skin, including babies and children.”
Who should skip it. Anyone whose washer is built for liquid only: the FAQ says “Some washers are designed to only use liquid detergent, so we would recommend checking your user’s manual.”
AspenClean Unscented Laundry Pods, 36 Count
Basis: EWG VERIFIED®, as AspenClean states it. AspenClean’s product page says its natural laundry pods are “EWG-Verified” and lists “EWG-Verified™” among the key features.
What is in them. AspenClean’s page lists sodium carbonate, sodium citrate, sodium carbonate peroxide, sodium sulfate, sodium oleate, sodium chloride, decyl glucoside, water, hydrated silica, coconut oil and a corn-derived alcohol, plus four enzymes: protease, alpha-amylase, mannanase and cellulase. The film is listed as “Polyvinyl Alcohol Polymer (water-soluble, biodegradable).” It describes the size as “396 g / 14 oz (36 Pods).”
How to use them. AspenClean says to “Put one unscented laundry detergent pod directly into the washing machine before adding laundry,” to use two for an extremely soiled or larger load, and that the pods “can be used at any desirable wash temperature in a standard or HE washing machine.” AspenClean describes the pods as “hypoallergenic.”
Maker’s caution. “Keep the container of unscented laundry pods closed when not in use. Store in a dry place, out of reach of children. Dry hands before handling eco-friendly laundry detergent pods or the container.”
Returns. AspenClean’s refund policy allows returns within 65 days but says “we only accept returns of items purchased directly from our website,” so it does not cover the Amazon link below. Our laundry pods guide and AspenClean review go deeper on the brand.
Pure Natural Laundry Detergent, Free & Clear
Basis: MADE SAFE® certified. The MADE SAFE registry entry for Pure Natural Laundry Detergent - Free & Clear reads “MADE SAFE® Certified in all currently available sizes / packaging options.” Our MADE SAFE laundry detergent guide compares it with Meliora.
What is in it. Pure Natural’s formula page describes its ingredients as Berry Saponin Concentrate, alkyl polyglucoside, aloe vera, vegetable glycerin, saponified coconut soap, sodium gluconate, natural phenethyl alcohol and xanthan gum.
How to use it. Its directions page says to pretreat stains by working the detergent into the fabric and, “For top load or HE machines,” to pump 4 times for normal loads and 6 to 7 times “For Larger loads or heavily soiled clothes.” The maker’s own refill product is “2x 32 oz detergent (Free & Clear),” and it notes “Color Variation to be expected as this is a natural product with no dyes.”
Babies and sensitive skin. Pure Natural’s about page says the company began after “our three children had allergies to chemical based laundry detergents.” That is the family’s own account, not a finding about the product.
What Do Authorities Say About Baby Laundry and Laundry Pods?
On baby clothes, the American Academy of Pediatrics’ HealthyChildren page says many parents wash baby clothes with the rest of the family’s laundry without problems, and that a milder or hypoallergenic or fragrance-free detergent is only called for if the baby develops signs of skin irritation.
On single-load liquid laundry detergent packets, AAP’s laundry safety page says: “If children age 6 years or younger live in or visit your home, consider purchasing traditional detergent products instead of single-load packets.” It adds: “If your child gets the contents of a laundry detergent packet in their mouth or eye, call Poison Help at 1-800-222-1222.”
CPSC’s 2013 release on liquid laundry packets recommends: “Keep the liquid laundry packets sealed in their original packaging, and make sure they are locked up and out of a child's sight and reach.” CPSC’s wording is about liquid laundry packets. Our swap guide for EWG-rated detergent alternatives and our EWG-rated laundry detergent guide list more options.
Our Picks
See Meliora Laundry Powder, Unscented, 128 HE loads, on Amazon →
See AspenClean Unscented Laundry Pods, 36 count, on Amazon →
See Pure Natural Laundry Detergent, Free & Clear, refill, on Amazon →
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between unscented and fragrance-free laundry detergent?
EPA’s Safer Choice criteria define the two labels differently: fragrance-free also rules out masking scents.
Is there a fragrance free laundry detergent with enzymes?
AspenClean’s unscented pods list four enzymes; Meliora’s ingredient list names none.
What is the best fragrance free laundry detergent powder?
Meliora Laundry Powder, Unscented.
Which unscented detergent works in an HE washer?
All three makers give HE directions: Meliora in the drum, an AspenClean pod in the drum, or Pure Natural by the pump.
What should I use for baby laundry?
AAP says many parents wash baby clothes with the family’s laundry without problems, and a milder or fragrance-free detergent is only called for if the baby develops signs of skin irritation.
Are laundry pods a good idea with small children at home?
AAP advises traditional detergent over single-load packets in homes where children age 6 or younger live or visit.
This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group or any certification program.



