This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (operated by Solved Labs LLC) earns commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with the Environmental Working Group.

Picking up a non toxic fabric softener starts with understanding what EWG flags about the bottle already in your laundry room. Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Softener, April Fresh earns a D in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning (ewg.org/cleaners), and the main reason is synthetic fragrance. The chemicals behind that "April Fresh" scent don't have to be individually disclosed on the label. EWG notes that fragrance formulas can cover dozens of undisclosed compounds — a concern that's amplified when the product stays on your clothes rather than rinsing off a surface.

The swap is direct: fragrance-free fabric softeners drop the synthetic fragrance entirely, removing the primary ingredient EWG flags. Several fragrance-free options score A in EWG's Guide, meaning EWG's ingredient data shows lower hazard concern across the full formula. This guide covers what EWG publishes about Downy Ultra, four A-rated picks verified in stock, and the practical side of switching. For households that want to skip chemical softeners altogether, see our companion piece on wool dryer balls.

What EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning Says About Downy Ultra

EWG rates household cleaning products A through F in its Guide to Healthy Cleaning, using ingredient hazard data, ingredient disclosure levels, and EWG's own toxicological review. A indicates the least concern; F indicates the highest.

Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Softener, April Fresh (product #1750 in EWG's database) earns a D. EWG's published assessment lists synthetic fragrance as the primary concern, noting that fragrance formulas can contain undisclosed chemicals with high data gaps. EWG published a piece in 2022 specifically flagging the most concerning fabric softeners, with Downy Ultra scented variants among those called out. Downy Ultra Spring Lavender (product #1754) receives the same D grade for the same reason.

These ratings are EWG's independent published assessments, not claims by NonToxicFinder. If you want to check your specific Downy variant, search the product name directly at ewg.org/cleaners — grades vary by variant and can change when formulations update.

Why Fragrance-Free Fabric Softeners Sidestep EWG's Concern

The EWG concern for Downy Ultra is specifically about synthetic fragrance and the undisclosed chemical blends that "fragrance" can legally cover on a product label. Fragrance-free fabric softeners don't use those blends. There's nothing to disclose because there's nothing there.

Beyond fragrance, a fragrance-free fabric conditioner still softens fabric through the same conditioning chemistry as a scented product — it just does so without the layer of synthetic scent chemicals stacking onto your laundry. For households with fragrance sensitivities, that matters independently of any EWG rating. For households following EWG's ratings, the A-grade picks below reflect EWG's ingredient review of the full formula, not just the fragrance concern.

4 Non Toxic Fabric Softener Picks EWG Rates A (or Low Hazard)

All four picks below were verified in stock on Amazon as of September 10, 2026. EWG ratings below are drawn from EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning (ewg.org/cleaners) and reflect EWG's published hazard data, not safety guarantees and not our own claims.

1. Dropps Fabric Softener Pods, Unscented

Price: $33.89 (64 pods) | EWG Status: Rates A in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning

Dropps Fabric Softener Pods are a pod-format softener that rates A in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning, the top grade in EWG's scale. Unscented, no synthetic fragrance, no dyes. The pod format is a practical differentiator: pre-measured, plastic-free packaging, no risk of overpouring. At $33.89 for 64 pods, the per-load cost works out to about $0.53, higher than Downy Ultra but reflecting the EWG-rated formula and zero-waste packaging. Dropps pods work in both standard and HE washers.

Dropps Fabric Softener Pods, Unscented (64 ct) on Amazon →

2. ATTITUDE Baby Fabric Softener, Unscented

Price: $14.99 (33.8 fl oz, 35 loads) | EWG Status: Rates LOW HAZARD in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning

ATTITUDE Baby Fabric Softener is a liquid fabric conditioner formulated for sensitive skin, particularly for baby and children's laundry. It rates LOW HAZARD in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning — that's EWG's lower-concern designation in the A range. The formula is unscented, free of synthetic fragrance, and designed for sensitive skin applications. At $14.99 for 35 loads, this is the most affordable liquid option on this list and a practical starting point for families making the switch. Works in HE and standard washers.

ATTITUDE Baby Fabric Softener, Unscented on Amazon →

3. The Clean People Liquid Fabric Softener, Fragrance Free

Price: $24.99 (50 fl oz) | EWG Status: From an EWG A-rated brand

The Clean People is a brand that rates A in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning across its cleaning line. The liquid fragrance-free fabric softener format is the most familiar swap for Downy users: same pour-in-the-softener-dispenser routine, just without the synthetic fragrance. At 50 fl oz, this is a large bottle and a good value for the price. If you're accustomed to liquid softener and want to keep that routine unchanged, this is the pick. Fragrance-free, vegan formula.

The Clean People Liquid Fabric Softener, Fragrance Free on Amazon →

4. Molly's Suds Fabric Softener Dryer Sheets, Unscented

Price: $13.99 (120 sheets) | EWG Status: Molly's Suds, an EWG A-rated laundry brand

Molly's Suds is a laundry brand whose products rate A in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning. These dryer sheets are unscented, made for sensitive skin, and come in at the lowest upfront price on this list: $13.99 for 120 sheets, about $0.12 per load. If you're coming from scented dryer sheets rather than liquid softener, this is the most direct format swap: same single-sheet-per-load routine, just without the synthetic fragrance. Works in all dryer types.

Molly's Suds Fabric Softener Dryer Sheets, Unscented (120 ct) on Amazon →

Making the Switch: Cost and Practical Notes

Downy Ultra typically runs $10 to $14 for a 51 fl oz bottle (about 64 loads), putting the per-load cost around $0.16 to $0.22. Here's how the picks above compare:

  • Molly's Suds dryer sheets ($13.99 / 120 sheets): $0.12/load — the cheapest per-load option
  • ATTITUDE Baby liquid ($14.99 / 35 loads): $0.43/load
  • The Clean People liquid ($24.99 / roughly 50 loads): $0.50/load
  • Dropps pods ($33.89 / 64 pods): $0.53/load

Molly's Suds dryer sheets come in under Downy's per-load cost, which makes the switch financially straightforward if you're open to the format change. Liquid-for-liquid replacements (ATTITUDE, Clean People) cost more per load than Downy but are in the same ballpark as other premium laundry products.

A practical note on transitioning: finish your current Downy bottle first, then buy one of the alternatives. There's no compatibility issue mixing, but using up what you have reduces waste. Most HE washers have a dedicated fabric softener dispenser — liquid options (ATTITUDE, Clean People) go directly there. Pods and dryer sheets go into the drum before drying.

For a deeper comparison of EWG-rated dryer sheets, liquid softeners, and the full laundry softener landscape, see the EWG-rated dryer sheets and fabric softener guide. To skip fabric softener products entirely and use a mechanical alternative with no ingredients to rate, see the wool dryer balls swap guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does EWG give Downy Ultra a D?
EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning rates Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Softener, April Fresh a D (product #1750) based on its ingredient assessment. The primary concern is synthetic fragrance. Fragrance is a legally protected trade secret on ingredient labels, meaning a single "fragrance" listing can cover dozens of undisclosed chemicals. EWG flags this as a high-concern data gap. These are EWG's published findings, not claims by NonToxicFinder.

Does fragrance-free fabric softener actually soften clothes?
Yes. The softening chemistry in fabric conditioners comes from cationic surfactants that coat fabric fibers — not from fragrance. The scent in conventional fabric softener is an add-on, not the softening mechanism. Removing fragrance from the formula has no effect on how the conditioner performs on your laundry. The picks above are the same conditioner chemistry, just without the synthetic scent layer.

Are these picks compatible with HE washers?
Yes. All four picks work in high-efficiency (HE) washers. Liquid options (ATTITUDE, Clean People) go into the fabric softener dispenser. Dropps pods and Molly's Suds dryer sheets go into the drum before drying. Check the product label for the HE-compatible symbol if you're uncertain about your specific washer model.

What if I want to skip fabric softener chemicals entirely?
Wool dryer balls are the alternative for households that want to skip chemical fabric softeners altogether. They soften fabric through physical agitation rather than a chemical coating, so there are no ingredients for EWG to rate. That's the approach for households that want to avoid the fabric softener category entirely. See our wool dryer balls swap guide for five verified picks starting at $8.97.