Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group.
Quick answer: It depends on the Downy product. EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning grades Downy Free & Gentle a B, Downy April Fresh a D, and both Downy Unstopables and the Cool Cotton dryer sheets an F. These are EWG's own published grades, not safety guarantees. Find your product below, then see the EWG-rated alternatives.
Downy is the market-leading fabric softener brand in the U.S., and most parents typing "is Downy safe" into a search bar already have a specific bottle or box in their laundry room. They want a sourced answer for that exact product, not a verdict on the whole Downy lineup. EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning grades Downy's formulas individually, and the results span nearly the full scale: one formula rates a B while others rate D or F. Here's what EWG's published data shows for each Downy product, and where EWG-rated alternatives exist for the ones that grade poorly.
Why This Page Answers "Is Downy Safe" Formula by Formula
Downy sells liquid softeners, scent boosters, and dryer sheets under dozens of scent and format variants, and EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning rates each one on its own, not the brand as a whole. A grade for one Downy product never applies to another. This page covers four distinctly-named Downy formulas with a sourced EWG grade: Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Conditioner, Free & Gentle; Downy Unstopables In-Wash Scent Booster; Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Softener, April Fresh; and Downy Fabric Softener Dryer Sheets, Cool Cotton.
What EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning Grades, and What It Doesn't
EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning scores products A through F using a weight-of-evidence approach that combines ingredient hazard data with how completely a brand discloses its formula on the label. It is not a government safety finding, a recall notice, or a clinical result, and it is not an endorsement or certification of Downy or any manufacturer. NonToxicFinder is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with EWG; the grades below are EWG's own published assessments.
Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Conditioner, Free & Gentle: EWG Grade B
Downy's unscented liquid conditioner, Free & Gentle, rates a B in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning, EWG's LOW HAZARD tier. Dropping synthetic fragrance is the main difference from Downy's scented lines, and it shows in the grade: this is the best-rated Downy formula checked for this article. It's a genuinely favorable result, not a spin, and it's worth stating plainly that not every Downy product scores poorly on EWG's scale.
Source: EWG Guide to Healthy Cleaning (ewg.org/cleaners), product 9462.
Downy Unstopables In-Wash Scent Booster: EWG Grade F
Downy Unstopables, the concentrated scent-bead booster added alongside regular detergent, rates an F in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning across both the Lush and Fresh scent variants checked. EWG flags concerns including fragrance-related asthma and respiratory effects, skin allergy and irritation, and a cancer-concern ingredient, alongside incomplete ingredient disclosure. This is Downy's lowest-rated formula covered here, and the concentrated fragrance is the primary driver.
Source: EWG Guide to Healthy Cleaning (ewg.org/cleaners), product 5663 (Lush) and product 2607 (Fresh).
Downy Ultra (April Fresh) and Downy Dryer Sheets (Cool Cotton): Previously Graded, Cross-Referenced
Two more Downy formulas already have a sourced EWG grade published on NonToxicFinder, and rather than re-report the same research here, this section links out to the full breakdown. Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Softener, April Fresh (EWG product #1750) rates a D, covered in detail in our guide to Downy Ultra's EWG grade and fragrance-free swaps. Downy Fabric Softener Dryer Sheets, Cool Cotton rates an F, covered in our comparison of Downy's dryer sheets against wool dryer balls. Both grades are EWG's independent, published assessments, not new findings derived for this article.
If Your Downy Formula Scores D or F: EWG-Rated Alternatives
The picks below are verified in stock and each carries exactly one stated EWG basis: an EWG Guide to Healthy Cleaning grade. For the full category roundup, see our full guide to EWG-rated dryer sheets and fabric softener.
Dropps Fabric Softener Pods, Unscented, 64 ct (ASIN: B014ABOU32, $33.89): EWG Guide to Healthy Cleaning, Grade A
Dropps' pod-format softener rates a Grade A in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning. Unscented, no synthetic fragrance, no dyes, in pre-measured, plastic-free packaging. A direct swap for either the Downy Unstopables booster or the D/F-graded liquid and dryer-sheet formulas above.
Dropps Fabric Softener Pods, Unscented, 64 ct: EWG Guide, Grade A : Buy on Amazon ↗
ATTITUDE Sensitive Fabric Softener, Free & Clear, Unscented, 35 Loads (ASIN: B01KA6AVLG, $13.21): EWG Guide to Healthy Cleaning, LOW HAZARD tier
ATTITUDE's fragrance-free liquid softener rates in EWG's Guide LOW HAZARD tier. It's the most familiar swap for Downy users who want to keep the same pour-in-the-dispenser routine without the synthetic fragrance the D and F-graded Downy formulas are flagged for.
ATTITUDE Sensitive Fabric Softener, Free & Clear, Unscented, 35 Loads: EWG Guide, LOW HAZARD : Buy on Amazon ↗
The Clean People Liquid Fabric Softener, Fragrance Free, 50 fl oz (ASIN: B0CKWGTKBP, $24.99): EWG Guide to Healthy Cleaning, A-rated brand
The Clean People rates A across its cleaning line in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning. This fragrance-free liquid softener is a large-bottle option for households that want to keep a liquid, pour-in routine while dropping synthetic fragrance entirely.
The Clean People Liquid Fabric Softener, Fragrance Free, 50 fl oz: EWG Guide, A-rated brand : Buy on Amazon ↗
Molly's Suds Fabric Softener Dryer Sheets, Sensitive Skin, Unscented, 120 ct (ASIN: B09FFT5SBB, $13.99): Molly's Suds, an EWG A-rated laundry brand
Molly's Suds is a laundry brand that rates A across its line in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning. These dryer sheets are unscented and made for sensitive skin, at the lowest per-sheet price on this list. If you're switching from Downy's Cool Cotton dryer sheets rather than a liquid softener, this is the most direct format swap: same single-sheet-per-load routine, without the synthetic fragrance the Cool Cotton sheets are flagged for.
Molly's Suds Fabric Softener Dryer Sheets, Sensitive Skin, Unscented, 120 ct: EWG A-rated brand : Buy on Amazon ↗
9 Elements Laundry Purifying Softener, Eucalyptus, 67 oz (ASIN: B08V7ZN4Z3, $35.58): EWG Guide to Healthy Cleaning, Grade A
9 Elements' liquid softener rates a Grade A in EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning. It's a plant-derived formula in a large 67 oz bottle, with a eucalyptus scent from essential oil rather than synthetic fragrance. A liquid, pour-in-the-dispenser option for households that want a scented (not unscented) pick without the synthetic-fragrance flags on Downy's D/F-graded formulas.
9 Elements Laundry Purifying Softener, Eucalyptus, 67 oz: EWG Guide, Grade A : Buy on Amazon ↗
How to Make the Switch
Finish your current Downy bottle or box before starting a new product; there's no compatibility issue mixing formulas across loads. Liquid alternatives (ATTITUDE, The Clean People, 9 Elements) go into the same dispenser Downy Ultra uses. Dropps pods and Molly's Suds dryer sheets go directly into the wash drum or dryer instead of the dispenser.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is Downy fabric softener bad for you?
EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning grades vary sharply by Downy formula, from a B for Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Conditioner, Free & Gentle down to an F for Downy Unstopables and the Cool Cotton dryer sheets. EWG grades are not government safety findings, and NonToxicFinder makes no independent health claim about any Downy product. Each grade reflects EWG's own assessment of the disclosed formula and ingredient transparency.
Q: Does every Downy product get the same EWG grade?
No. EWG grades individual formulas and SKUs, not brands as a whole. Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Conditioner, Free & Gentle rates B, Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Softener, April Fresh rates D, and both Downy Unstopables and Downy Fabric Softener Dryer Sheets, Cool Cotton rate F. A grade for one Downy product never applies to another.
Q: What does EWG flag about Downy's ingredients?
Across the lower-graded formulas, EWG's most frequently cited concerns are synthetic fragrance and incomplete ingredient disclosure, along with asthma/respiratory and skin allergy flags tied to fragrance and quaternary ammonium compounds. These are EWG's published findings, not claims by NonToxicFinder.
Q: Is there a Downy formula that scores well on EWG's Guide?
Yes. Downy Ultra Liquid Fabric Conditioner, Free & Gentle rates a B, EWG's LOW HAZARD tier, the best grade among the Downy formulas checked for this article. Dropping synthetic fragrance is the main reason for the higher grade.
Q: Does EWG certify or endorse Downy?
No. EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning grades are the independent work of the Environmental Working Group and are not an endorsement, partnership, or certification of Downy or its parent company. NonToxicFinder is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with EWG.
EWG Disclaimer: All product ratings, grades, and the EWG VERIFIED® mark are the independent work of the Environmental Working Group (ewg.org). NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with EWG. EWG ratings reflect EWG's assessment methodology and are not government safety findings or health guarantees. Verify current ratings at ewg.org before purchasing.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. NonToxicFinder (Solved Labs LLC) may earn commissions on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or partnered with the Environmental Working Group.
